The Democratic Party’s biggest problem is that too many people see its adherents as censorious, inquisitorial, joyless, gatekeeping and overall more interested in ideological purity than in governing effectively or addressing the concerns of everyday people. This is a problem in a country like America with nonconformism in its political DNA.

As a result, the party has almost completely lost what we might call “downscale voters.” This is a broader group than the so-called “white working class.”

It encompasses anyone whose hobbies (toying with firearms), media consumption (preferring “Yellowstone” to “Succession”), cultural interests (enjoying mixed martial arts, not NPR), views of sex (insisting men are men and women are women), job descriptions (using physical tools), religious views (believing the same things as their grandparents), educational goals (training for a well-paying job) and so on alienate them from an apparent respectability consensus.

It is impossible to consistently win national elections in the United States without being competitive among downscale voters.

Advertise with us

Aggressively seeking to oust U.S. Sen. John Fetterman — Axios reported last week that several high-profile Democrats are eyeing the race — will only worsen the party’s problems among these crucial nonconformists.

Pennsylvania maverick

Anyone who expected Mr. Fetterman to be a doctrinaire progressive in the Senate wasn’t paying attention to his career, or his “every county, every vote” campaign. He has long delighted in spurning elite expectations, and demonstrated a willingness to connect with voters (especially downscale voters) across the commonwealth. This was ultimately successful, as he consistently outperformed Trump-era Democrats in small Pennsylvania counties in his 2022 race against Mehmet Oz.

No one, however, expected him to be quite this maverick. It’s not just his approach to policy, like his borderline obsequious support for the Israeli government. It’s his willingness to undermine his own party’s strategies and interests, such as endorsing ending the filibuster to reopen the government, which would thereafter allow the Republican majority to steamroll Senate Democrats.

It’s easy to understand why a partisan Democrat might want a more predictable and reliable presence in the upper chamber. A Quinnipiac poll recently found that a majority, 54%, of Pennsylvania Democrats disapproved of Mr. Fetterman’s performance. Meanwhile, hilariously, 62% of the state’s Republicans are now favorable toward the Carhartt-chic senator.

This has prompted speculation that Mr. Fetterman might switch parties, or at least become independent, if faced with a robust primary challenge. While many Democrats might cheer this outcome, chasing Mr. Fetterman out of the Senate or the party would do the party more harm than good.

Advertise with us

MAGA’s advantage

The fact that Mr. Fetterman is a walking rebuke to the contemporary Democratic Party is exactly why the party needs to retain him. Getting rid of him would only confirm, especially among the nonconformist voters the party needs, that Democrats can’t abide anyone outside the left-elite consensus.

The obvious counterargument is that Republicans have the same problem, if not worse, because being in good standing with the GOP is almost entirely defined as loyalty to a single man, President Donald Trump. Surely voters are at least as turned off by Republicans turning on Kentucky’s Sen. Rand Paul and Rep. Thomas Massie as they would be by Democrats turning on Mr. Fetterman.

They aren’t. Voters have shown with their ballots — this is one way to read the 2024 election — that for better or worse they’re less offended by the Republicans’ cult of personality than they are by Democrats’ tone- and doctrine-policing.

Because MAGA’s organizing principle is a person, not an ideology, the movement tolerates more political diversity — of course within the constantly shifting boundaries set by Mr. Trump. In short, more people (especially downscale or nonconformist) feel welcome in a personal party than an ideological one.

While Mr. Trump has pursued a broadly pro-Israel policy, there’s a strong and growing anti-Israel contingent on the right — but they aren’t ostracized. While Mr. Trump is responsible for overturning Roe v. Wade, no one thinks he’s personally anti-abortion, and a wide variety of views on reproductive issues coexist, vying for his attention and approbation, within the movement. By contrast, there are almost no remaining pro-life elected Democrats.

Advertise with us

Even on Mr. Trump’s signature issue, immigration, there are differences, most notably among tech allies who depend on H1-B visas. Yet these disagreements do not typically result in excommunication, so long as dissenters remain personally loyal.

Shunning nonconformists

The Democrats’ excommunicating John Fetterman for heresy would merely confirm that the party is a church of the elect, a vehicle for the true, pure believers, and not a broad-based political movement in which nonconformist and downscale voters have an important place.

Now, if evidence were to continue to mount that Mr. Fetterman lacks the competence or good health to fulfill his duties, that would be a different question, and a different campaign. But right now the focus of intraparty attacks on Mr. Fetterman has been more about the soundness of his views than of his mind or body.

And that’s exactly how to communicate to voters who have deserted the Democrats in recent years that nothing has changed, that nonconformists are still not welcome and that the party is more interested in moral preening than representing real-life Americans.

Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “What Pittsburgh can learn from a thriving West Virginia town.”