Mountaineers won’t be free until everyone is free,” read the sign in the window of an art studio in Thomas, W.Va. It’s a leftist spin on West Virginia’s motto, Montani sember liberi, “Mountaineers are always free,” asserting that trans rights, Palestinian rights and so on must be integral to any righteous political project, or claim to liberty.

I was walking down this Main Street after a two-day adventure in the glorious Dolly Sods National Wilderness, a sparse and windswept terrain where you expect bands of hobbits or elves to amble by at any moment. Thomas is an old coal town that’s become an outdoorsy hotspot, and a center of Appalachian progressivism: pride flags, disparaging slogans about ICE and Israel, signs opposing a nearby data center project.

And also: some of the coolest shops and cafes and galleries you’ll find between Pittsburgh and Washington, D.C. I joked that we’d stumbled into a hill-and-holler version of Lawrenceville. Or, these days, Garfield.

My backpacking group, none of us partisans of the left, were forced to agree that if you want to revitalize a moribund town, you call in the progressives. But why hasn’t that worked in Pittsburgh?

Advertise with us

Small is beautiful

It’s sometimes said, or simply assumed, that progressive politicians and their supporters don’t care about economic development.

But this isn’t fair. Sure, hard-core leftists just want to burn the system to the ground. Progressives who actually want to make things better within the constraints of reality, however, include the market as part of the way to rebuild and sustain communities.

Their efforts don’t look like traditional economic development. There’s no elephant-hunting for massive corporations, subsidies to attract job-creators or public-private partnerships to prepare sites and sign deals. There’s an emphasis on the small, and specifically the arts. This means neighborhood co-ops, thrift stores, bookshops with cats, music venues that seat 13 people and cafes with shelves full of complicated board games.

The idea is to facilitate the kind of businesses everyday people can open and operate, and which fit into the existing fabric of a community. The kind of businesses that probably won’t make them rich, but might bring decent financial security while also providing a clear public benefit.

And here’s the thing: It works. Just drive (or, better, walk) down Butler, Penn or Liberty. Or swing by the left-wing Mountaineer Mayberry in Tucker County.

Advertise with us

Big is necessary

This is essentially the progressive economic development vision for all of Pittsburgh: weird, small, cool. Outside help — that is, big brands or big capital — is neither needed nor welcome.

I’m on board. Small is beautiful. To quote another banner in Thomas, this one for sale in a wonderful country boutique, “Support your local everything.”

Yet while tiny Thomas has grown by more than a third since hitting rock bottom in the 2000 census, Pittsburgh is getting lapped by peer cities in job growth and renewed dynamism. Which points to the problem: Small-is-beautiful economic development doesn’t scale, and depends on larger forces to be viable. Barring a radical transformation of our economic system, it can only be part of a broader strategy that includes big investments, big construction, big ambition.

Take opposition to data centers. I get it: They’re monstrous blights on the landscape. They’re shameless gluttons for the scarce resource of energy. In my perfect world, neither they nor the technology that necessitates them would exist.

Yet in this world, data centers are the entrance ticket to the emerging economy that, like it or not, is going to be shaped by AI. Choosing not to play this game might bring righteous satisfaction, but it will also radically limit economic opportunities — not just profits for Silicon Valley magnates, but the kind of jobs and businesses that generate the wealth (and the taxes) needed to build and to sustain weird, small, cool neighborhoods.

Advertise with us

In other words, Pittsburgh’s cool corridors depend on the kind of enormous, soulless economic infrastructure their architects consider to be anathema. There’s no Garfield or Bloomfield without CMU, PNC and UPMC. There’s no Thomas without the outdoor recreation economy sustained by the enormous apparel and gear industries, and a growing economy that gives people the money to travel to cool mountain communities.

All of the above

If you’ve only watched “The Lords of the Rings” movies, you might not know what happens to the Shire at the end of the book. The idyllic home of the hobbits — verdant, peaceful, happily heedless of the troubles of the world beyond — is destroyed by the dark wizard Saruman.

The Shire can only be the Shire if hard people attuned to the darker ways of the world have created an environment where it can survive. Everything cannot be the Shire.

Given the reality of human imperfection, grassroots communities — whether in West Virginia, the East End or Middle Earth — require powerful forces to sustain and protect them. Everything cannot be Lawrenceville or Garfield or Thomas.

Yes, we should aim to build more small-is-beautiful neighborhoods that honor their communities and keep capital close to home. But we also need leaders who understand that a region of more than 2 million people can only have pockets of cool and weird if it’s also dynamic and growing, which means courting big businesses and competing for big investments.

Advertise with us

Small may be beautiful, but big is necessary.

Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “Sidney Crosby is a remarkable man.”