Never, at least since Gallup began polling this question in 2001, have fewer Americans expressed pride in their country. Fifty-eight percent, the polling agency reports, say they are “very” or “extremely proud” of the United States.

Democrats, according to Gallup’s polling over the years, struggle to muster national pride to the level Republicans do, even during Democratic administrations. In the Biden years, even as MAGA voters expressed profound distrust of America’s public and private institutions, and rejected so-called wokeness, they persisted in a generalized sense of pride in the United States — perhaps as an ideal, perhaps as something more tangible — scoring at least 25 points higher than Democrats.

But the most striking crosstabs measure national pride by age: It declines sharply as generational cohorts get younger. More than three-quarters of Americans born before 1965 retain high levels of pride: The love of country instilled earlier in life, it appears, resists erosion by political dysfunction. For Gen Z, the oldest of whom are approaching 30 years old, that figure drops to around 40%. And for Gen Z Democrats, it’s only 24%.

While for some, contemporary politics complicates an established and enduring love of country, for others this dysfunction, combined with a much more critical history education, is all they’ve ever known. What is there to love in such a country that has produced, well, this?

Advertise with us

Confronting complication

This is a question I was forced to confront some years ago, when I became more serious about my Catholic faith. The uncomplicated patriotism of a kid who put a Bush-Cheney bumper sticker on his high school locker began to melt away in the face of higher ideals.

I began to look at America’s founding principles and history with a more critical eye. I didn’t realize, because this is glossed over in most history education, how hostile this country’s leaders and institutions were to the Catholic Church for so long. Indeed, in coded language, the Declaration of Independence itself lists the establishment of a Catholic government, that of Quebec, near the colonies’ borders among the outrages worth revolting over.

This helped me, finally, see U.S. history more clearly through the eyes of other groups of people who’ve been considered beyond the reach of, or threatening to, the nation’s high-minded principles.

And I began to see in some of those principles — a thoroughgoing individualism, a suspicion of hierarchy and authority, a form of secularism with roots in England’s anti-clerical traditions — ideas I couldn’t affirm, and that might even be seen as deep pathologies in the American character, slowly sickening the patient over the generations.

Honoring our gifts

My path was unusual, but I think analogous to that of many Americans today, left and right and center, whose feelings for their country have become complicated, unsettled, disillusioned. To some degree or another, both current events and new understandings of history have left people wondering if their idea of America is real, or ever was. What now?

Advertise with us

For me, the path forward required two revelations: sharpening my understanding of patriotism, and expanding my view of America, and of how to love her.

First, I came to understand that patriotism, classically, is not an emotion or even a conviction but a virtue. That means it’s good in itself, and we can work at developing it.

Specifically, patriotism is the honor we owe the country from which we derive so many tangible and intangible benefits: attachment to its culture and history, the protection of its laws, the opportunity to pursue prosperity and happiness and other goods, a land to call home. It is related to the honor we owe to our parents, and to their parents, and so on, no matter how imperfect they may be.

But most of all, our country and our families are simply ours: They are where we have been placed to do good in the world.

This made me realize that even if my feelings about my country had become more complicated, the honor I express by, say, my posture and attention during the national anthem doesn’t have to. In fact, it mustn’t.

Advertise with us

This land is our land

Second, I stopped thinking about America as just a collection of ideals. This is a distinctively American self-perception, but one that I’ve come to believe is not just faulty but dangerous.

That’s because this country, like every country, has regularly failed and will regularly fail — sometimes spectacularly — to live up to those ideals. And if that’s all America is, then those failures can easily seem to indicate the failure of America.

But America is also a land, and cultures and people informed by that land. They are wildly diverse and constantly evolving, but that doesn’t make them less real. They are what we all share, even as we share ideas and ideals less and less.

I realized that my love of this country was at least as much about my love of them — of the escarpments looming over the Ohio River valley, of the legend and the reality of the West, of the tidal swamps of the Lowcountry, of the music of Appalachia and Memphis and New Orleans, of the foodways we’ve adopted from everywhere and made our own — as it was about intellectual abstractions.

And they will always be there, no matter who is president, and no matter how far the American reality appears to have strayed from the American idea.

Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “July 15 will be the biggest day for Pittsburgh in decades.”