One of the very unusual aspects of Pittsburgh’s mayoral primary has been the amount written about it by national and international publications that have no connection to, knowledge of or previous interest in the Steel City. Particularly curious has been how every article has the exact same thesis.

“Republican donors trying to unseat Pittsburgh’s progressive Black mayor,” writes The Guardian, a left-leaning British newspaper. “Trump donors try to buy Pittsburgh’s mayor’s race,” blares the headline at The Intercept, a left-wing online publication. “MAGA money targets Pittsburgh’s progressive mayor,” says a piece by a correspondent for The Nation, the once-venerable progressive magazine.

These are obviously stories planted by Mayor Ed Gainey’s allies in the national progressive movement and published by editors who know they’ll generate clicks. It’s capitalism at its finest.

More importantly, it represents a clear attempt to nationalize what has become, and must remain, a race based on deeply local concerns. Despite simplistic analyses from Washington or even London, the result of this primary will say absolutely nothing about the national mood.

Advertise with us

But it’ll say a great deal about Pittsburgh’s mood.

Know when to fold ‘em

Attempting to plot Mr. Gainey and his challenger, long-time City Councilman and current Allegheny County Controller Corey O’Connor, on an ideological spectrum is the easiest way to lose the thread in understanding this election. This isn’t a race between a progressive and a MAGA-inflected moderate (as Mr. Gainey would have it) or a race between two barely distinguishable progressives (as some cynics would have it).

It’s a race between a man who’s proven beyond a doubt he’s not up for the job and a man who plausibly could be up for the job. It’s a choice between doubling down on an unwinnable hand and folding a loser in order to be dealt fresh cards.

At least that’s what this race is, and will continue to be, if it’s decided based on what’s happening in Pittsburgh. That’s why Mr. Gainey is invoking President Donald Trump every chance he gets. That’s why it feels like the mayor of Pittsburgh is running for Pennsylvania Avenue rather than a second term on Grant Street.

Alternative facts

Take the press conference Mr. Gainey hosted alongside U.S. Rep. Summer Lee last week deploring the possible closure of the Pittsburgh field office of the Department of Housing and Urban Development, despite the fact no such action has been proposed. There he was, champion of the oppressed against the evil emanating from Washington.

Advertise with us

Where has this champion been as the Housing Authority of the City of Pittsburgh, over which Mr. Gainey actually has some measure of control, has contributed through its (at best) rank incompetence to the city’s housing crisis? Hundreds if not thousands of Section 8-eligible households don’t have vouchers because the HACP makes it fantastically difficult for small landlords to participate in the program, limiting the availability of affordable housing.

Even City Council’s most stalwart progressive, Barb Warwick, has said that her husband doesn’t accept Section 8 at his several properties because the system is broken. Yet, despite the fact Mr. Gainey’s former chief of staff Jake Wheatley chaired the HACP board, there has been little to no progress in reforming the agency or helping more low-income Pittsburghers access Section 8. Much easier, it seems, to deflect to D.C. than to make real progress at home.

And when Mr. Gainey does try to tout his Pittsburgh-based accomplishments, the claims have a decidedly Trumpian quality. In recent weeks, either in interviews or in his campaign literature, Mr. Gainey has alternately claimed to have created 850, 1,000, 1,400 and 2,000 units of affordable housing. Lucky for him, as far as I can tell every local outlet that has printed his claims has done so without pointing out this flagrant inconsistency, or asking him to substantiate his claims.

Already lost

The Democratic primary for mayor of Pittsburgh is not a referendum on Donald Trump, and the vast majority of Pittsburghers understand that. The only reason for the incumbent to try to make it one is if he can’t successfully run on his own record.

This race isn’t about applying ideological labels to the candidates, like progressive or moderate (or MAGA). It’s about being able to stand before Pittsburgh voters and declare, without making up facts as you go, what you’ve done to make this city a better place to live.

Advertise with us

That’s ultimately why Mr. O’Connor is attracting the kind of money, including cross-party money, that’s typically reserved for the incumbent mayor. For most of the nominally Republican and property development donors Mr. Gainey claims to deplore — many of whom have given to him in the past, even in this election cycle — political giving is a strategic expense reserved for incumbents and front-runners, not an ideological statement.

They aren’t giving to the challenger because Mr. Gainey is an avowed progressive, or because Mr. O’Connor is a secret conservative. They’re doing it because Mr. Gainey is historically weak, and it’s better to be on the side of a winner.

Because if you’re trying to win by using The Guardian, in all likelihood you’ve already lost Pittsburgh.

Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “Pittsburgh's pretty safe. But without enough cops, it won't stay that way.”