One of the strangest political developments in this strange political moment is the dominance of conservative revolutionaries within the Republican Party. What isn’t new at all, however, is the sensibility this movement has given voice to: overwhelming distrust of, and willingness to overthrow, well-established social institutions in every area from education to medicine to government.
It continues to confound those who trust and value these institutions, and certainly those who work in and for them, that despite the assault on them, President Donald Trump has not seen (at least yet) a significant drop in popularity. Americans as a whole seem not to care or to applaud their demotion.
Take, for instance, attempts to significantly pare back National Institutes of Health grants, which would devastate the entire university system. (It would defund the University of Pittsburgh alone of $150 million per year.) The federal underwriting of the scientific and educational establishment was assumed by its direct beneficiaries — researchers, professors, administrators — to have been politically untouchable because it sustains college communities and facilitates progress, especially medical discoveries, for all.
But they underestimated the extent of the revolutionary fervor Mr. Trump’s victory unleashed, and overestimated their perceived importance in the social order, and therefore the security of their status. It’s a mistake made time and again in human history by the clerical class, which is always among the first to go when the prevailing order breaks down.
Necessary or noxious
Before the November election, I argued that Mr. Trump would prevail because a critical mass of voters were fed up with people who hold modern “titles of nobility” — college presidencies, nonprofit directorships, newspaper editorships. But the targeted class is more like the clerisy than the nobility.
Every society has a clerical class: the professionals whose work is inaccessible to most people and not immediately economically productive, but is perceived to be essential to the proper functioning of society, and therefore receives both public subsidy and special status.
In most societies through history, this class was made up of what we might call spiritual professionals, such as priests, who dedicated their lives to prayer and esoteric rituals. The masses believed their work ensured the well-being of their societies, by imploring God’s favor or deflecting his wrath, and so they were happy to underwrite them.
Until, one day, they don’t believe. The problem for the clerical class is that its position is entirely dependent on the trust — or faith — of the people. Its work is, by definition, mysterious and its public value difficult to pin down, unless you have a deep understanding of its methods, which most people do not. Otherwise, you must take the practitioners’ word for it.
When that trust breaks down, however, the clerical class suddenly shifts from being seen as indispensable to parasitic. That’s why some of the worst depredations of the French Revolution and the Spanish Civil War were visited on the clergy. It’s why Mao’s Great Leap Forward and Cultural Revolution targeted the modern clerisy: the academic and expert classes.
Heretic hunting
Now, the obvious objection is that the spiritual professionals were actually parasites, while today’s practitioners of the scientific method (or, for that matter, the esoterica of bureaucracy) are actually indispensable. But that’s exactly what the priests thought, too, right before people decided they weren’t.
The important thing, as a matter of history and politics, isn’t whether the clerical class is actually useful. It’s whether enough people are convinced it’s useful enough to keep supporting it. The truth is that today, what happens in laboratories and federal office buildings is just as inscrutable, and therefore suspicious, to many people as what happened behind medieval rood screens.
It would be tempting here to blame lack of education or misinformation (just like churches blamed heretics), which certainly contribute to anti-clericalism. But we mustn’t ignore how the modern clerical class, just like its predecessors, has also undermined its own credibility.
Consider, for instance, the replication crisis. The conclusions of most published scientific research cannot be confirmed by a second researcher repeating the experiment, and many of those papers were the basis for public policy. This can’t be waved away as “just how science works.” It shows that how the clerisy practices science isn’t working, and needs reform.
More important for most people, however, was the constantly changing guidance during the COVID pandemic, exemplified by the exception to bans on mass gatherings granted to approved social justice protests. Nothing is more dangerous to the clerical class than when it appears to pick political sides — and then that side loses.
Decadence and reform
Societies need a clerical class. They always need necessary work done — spiritual or scientific — that only subsidized experts can do. Everyone suffers when this work isn’t done. But this class also, by its very nature, habitually becomes complacent and self-satisfied, even self-serving.
Our modern clerical class needs a good shakeup, a reminder that no matter how important it is, it still needs to keep on-side the everyday people whose tax dollars fund it. That means being self-reflective, humble about its work, accountable to the people and open to reform.
But revolutions rarely know when to stop, and if this one decimates the clerisy without improving it, everyone in America will be worse off.
Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “Is Pittsburgh doomed?”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.