Every day in the Pittsburgh region, about 20 more people die than are born. That means more than 20 people have to move here every day to make up for them, or southwestern Pennsylvania will never escape the decline that began roughly 70 years ago.

No other major metro region in America has it this bad. While we lose 0.3% of our residents to natural population change (births minus deaths) every year, Cleveland loses 0.1%. Baltimore and Cincinnati gain 0.2%. Most regions gain more.

The percentages may seem small, but they compound like interest. If trends continue, without significant migration (domestic or international) to offset the decline, the region will lose at least another 200,000 people by 2050, and will likely fall into the mid-30s by size, behind Columbus, Kansas City and Nashville.

Pittsburgh is slowly dying. Yet, the region retains the institutional and natural resources to be indispensable once again. The question is whether we can generate a regional vision, and raise up leadership to make it reality.

Advertise with us

Terminal decline?

I am indebted for this data and insight to University of Pittsburgh demographer Chris Briem, who brings out the natural-population-decline chart anytime someone confidently predicts Pittsburgh is one or two policies away from becoming a booming young metro like Austin or Charlotte. We aren’t, not even close.

Where I depart from Mr. Briem is in his view that Pittsburgh can be sustainably prosperous without population growth. That may be possible in theory, but in practice stagnation breeds dissension and dysfunctional politics, which makes the region less desirable to live in or move to, which leads right back to cascading decline.

Natural population decline is very difficult to turn around — especially when the region is also losing jobs, to the tune of 2.1% since the pandemic, another national low.

Decline is baked into Pittsburgh’s demographic destiny for decades to come, unless the region brings in a significant new cohort of young people who raise families here and whose children stay here. And that requires a dynamic economy — one that creates new businesses, builds housing, improves schools and offers opportunities to advance — to attract and retain new residents who are looking to make big commitments for the long haul.

Five requirements

Is this possible? Yes, I believe it is, but only with significant changes to the city’s political landscape and leadership structures. Here is a very brief sketch of what it will require.

Advertise with us

Pittsburgh must capitalize on its strengths. The region has huge competitive advantages in education and geography. Pitt’s BioForge and the new AI Strike Team are aiming to harness cutting-edge research for regional economic growth — but there are too few examples of this, and they aren’t part of a complete strategy. As for geography, besides the ongoing shale gas boom, Pittsburgh’s river valleys should be prime candidates for a resurgence of nuclear power, especially small modular reactors possibly paired with data centers.

The future is for-profit. Pittsburgh’s enormous eds-and-meds nonprofit sector, not to mention its foundation community, likely saved the city from Detroit-like collapse. But they aren’t enough to power a dynamic economy on their own, and won’t attract enough talented and ambitious people to build a fresh, competitive business ecosystem. That means not just nurturing existing entrepreneurship, but offering aggressive incentives to established businesses. Operating in Pittsburgh is not a privilege: We have to make it worth their while.

New regional leadership groups must arise. Legacy civic institutions like the Allegheny Conference on Community Development were created in a different economic and political environment, with more big corporations headed by homegrown leaders. Now, with the same 100 or so people on every board in the city, this system has become comfortable and complacent. Despite yeoman’s work by figures like Highmark’s David Holmberg and PNC’s Bill Demchak, it simply can’t drive a regional agenda any longer. The recent emergence of Pittsburgh Tomorrow shows there’s a void to be filled.

Pittsburgh will look very different. This is a hard one for me to swallow, because I love my city as it is, but it has to change. This is a region of old buildings as well as old people, and some communities will have to be radically transformed in order to meet the moment. Municipal mergers will become inevitable and irresistible, because they will become matters of survival. A truly thriving region will require major changes to the built and political environments.

The city will likely need a single leader. To cut through the endlessly complex system of political relationships and mutual back-scratching; to hold and to execute a single consistent vision; to rally stakeholders, including powerful ones with complex and contradictory interests, behind that vision; to persuade everyday people that change is necessary to avoid terminal decline: It will take one person of extraordinary political skill, possibly elected but more likely some other kind of leader, to guide Pittsburgh to the future its people deserve.

Advertise with us

Modest goal

Pittsburgh is battling the most severe demographic headwinds of any region in America. That’s all the more reason we must make population growth our primary goal, and metric of success.

But we must also be realistic. A region with more deaths than births can’t become a boomtown overnight. So let me propose a benchmark: aggregate 5% population growth by the 2050 census, which means adding 120,000 people rather than losing 200,000. To achieve that, the Pittsburgh region would have to grow by 0.2% per year, which means actually getting to 0.5% annual growth through increased migration and retention (given the 0.3% natural decline). That’s about what Indianapolis is getting right now.

Every regional leader, elected and unelected, should publicly commit to this reachable goal. The alternative is settling for a slow death.

Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “‘The wheels are coming off’ the Gainey administration.”