This week, two young men have been celebrated for killing. The first, Daniel Penny, placed a belligerent subway rider, Jordan Neely, in a chokehold in the tunnels beneath New York City. Mr. Neely died, and on Monday Mr. Penny was acquitted of all charges.
The second, Luigi Mangione, is alleged to have shot to death Brian Thompson, the CEO of major insurance company UnitedHealthcare, on a sidewalk in Manhattan. Mr. Mangione is being held in a Pennsylvania prison pending extradition to New York.
These two incidents raise some of the thorniest questions in morality and law. Who is justified in killing? Who deserves to die? And, most importantly of all for the American social fabric, who gets to decide?
The first two questions will always be contested. But the third requires unanimity, or near to it, that the state can be trusted to decide. If that fails, and a critical mass of people no longer trust those institutions, then vigilante violence will only continue, and worsen.
Contingent commandment
Ending another person’s life is not, strictly speaking, against either the civil or moral law. This may sound startling, but everyone but doctrinaire pacifists believes it.
Even the most concise prohibition on killing — “thou shalt not kill” — has always been understood to be contingent. From Biblical times to the present, it has gone without saying that while it may be wrong to take an innocent life, it’s also possible to forfeit one’s own.
Today, the only circumstance in which it is still (nearly) universally held that one can forfeit one’s own life is in threatening to violate another’s. This triggers the right to self-defense, which recognizes the dignity of human life by privileging the innocent defender against an unjust aggressor.
As for punishment after the fact, while the death penalty has fallen into abeyance, prisons fulfill the idea that violating moral and community standards forfeits one’s freedom and place in the community.
At the most basic level, the purpose of a state’s system of justice is to adjudicate these questions of liberty, life and death. Because if it doesn’t do so, then every person will be free to decide for themselves who’s allowed to kill, and who deserves to die. And that is anarchy.
Justifying vigilantism
On that fateful subway ride, no one contests that Mr. Neely, the homeless and mentally ill panhandler, menaced passengers on the train. Mr. Penny then held Mr. Neely in a chokehold for several minutes, after which Mr. Neely died.
Self-defense is morally and legally complicated, and it’s very difficult to pass judgment without having witnessed the event itself. For my part, I believe that Mr. Penny’s actions reflected a disquieting lack of concern for Mr. Neely’s well-being — having spoken to a person who received similar military training, the duration of Mr. Penny’s chokehold likely represented either incompetence or malice — but also that, as a matter of law, we must give significant latitude for defense of oneself and others.
The public discourse, however, hasn’t focused on the nuances. Instead, the case has come to represent — to people on both sides — the decline of American civil institutions and order.
For some, Mr. Penny is obviously a hero, reasserting order in a society that has slipped into chaos. For others, he is obviously a villain, declaring himself the arbiter of life and death and thereby participating in the anarchy he claims to oppose.
Commentators have largely sorted themselves into one of these two camps: The former assumes that our civic institutions cannot be trusted to preserve order; and, after the acquittal, the latter concludes that our civic institutions cannot be trusted to preserve justice.
Both of these could serve as justifications for vigilantism, leaving each person to fulfill the responsibilities the institutions are failing to perform. And that’s exactly the attitude that has been surfaced by the alleged shooting by, and resulting folk-hero status of, Luigi Mangione.
Getting away with murder
The Thompson killing is morally and legally much simpler: The CEO presented no immediate threat to anybody, so shooting him in the back was murder, cut-and-dried.
Yet that’s exactly why the ambivalent public reaction has been so startling. It’s clear that many millions of Americans believe that, by virtue of the suffering caused by UnitedHealthcare’s business practices, Brian Thompson’s life was just as forfeit as a common killer’s — and certainly more so than a menacing subway surfer’s.
In the abstract, they may be right. It may well be that Mr. Thompson was guilty of heinous moral crimes, the kind of injustices that call to heaven for vengeance. It may well be that he was the perfect avatar for an evil industry.
But that was not Luigi Mangione’s role to decide. It’s the role of America’s justice system to investigate and prosecute violations of the law, and of America’s legislatures to change the law if it’s allowing people and businesses to get away with murder. It was the role of the state to declare Mr. Thompson’s life or freedom forfeit, not a troubled young man or a social media mob.
What happens, though, when more and more Americans believe their country’s institutions are too corrupt to get it right, to root out injustice, to decide rightly who gets to kill and who deserves to die? Then, I fear, more and more Americans will make those choices for themselves.
Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “The IRS lost two of my children.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.