After Tuesday, there is no going back. Any attempt to recreate the political norms and coalitions of the pre-Trump era will fail. It is now clear that Joe Biden was an aberration, who never would have been president were it not for the upheaval of the COVID pandemic. The era of Clinton and Bush and Obama has been superseded.
Donald Trump is the man of the moment, not because he created this moment, but because he reflects the borderline revolutionary spirit that has swept over what we now see is a majority of Americans. And if those who oppose him aren’t careful, that spirit could continue to spread.
Yes, there are reasons to discount the long-term political implications of these election results. The shift to Trump in the battleground states was ultimately pretty small, a little more than 3% on average compared to 2020, just enough to flip them red. The president-elect’s coattails were not long: Republicans will barely take the House, and appear to have lost four Senate races in states he won.
And the Democrats’ defeat occurred in the context of an international wave of anti-incumbency elections, driven by the unique circumstance of the post-pandemic world. In fact, compared to ruling parties in other countries, the shift in the presidential race is among the lowest of any election this year.
Yet everyone knows, in their mind or their heart or their gut, that this election — this rout — was something different, that its importance can’t be measured with percentage points. This was an election that changed the political landscape for good — or, more accurately, that has revealed a permanent rupture in the public’s relationship with its leaders and institutions.
Majority rule
Trump voters are cruel, stupid, selfish, sexist, racist — I’ve seen it all, and more, over the last few days on social media. I’m sure many of them are, just as surely as some Harris voters have their own serious defects, just as surely as every man and woman on earth has impure motives and imperfect reason.
These insults and epithets are meant above all else to distinguish the sheep from the goats, but after Tuesday they’ve lost their power. Because, as a matter of pure power politics, they don’t matter anymore. Whether or not those people are cruel or stupid or selfish or sexist or racist, they are the majority, and they are growing among nearly every demographic slice of America.
It’s now clear that any political movement that desires to succeed, rather than merely to peacock its moral and intellectual credentials, must appeal to at least some of those people, and not just condemn them. That means — and this could be a great leap forward for our politics — a successful movement must seek to understand them, not as an anthropologist studies an uncontacted tribe, but, as my colleague David Mills has done, on their own terms and as equals.
Political alienation
What an honest student of Trump’s America will find is that many, many people feel profoundly alienated from the political life of their own country. This is why, according to a CNN exit poll, a slight majority of those who believe American democracy is “threatened” voted for Trump.
This sense of alienation is the through line that connects all the major issues Trump voters cite. Inflation wasn’t just about high prices, but about being told by the people in charge that inflation wasn’t actually so bad.
Immigration wasn’t just about the question of migration itself, but about the sense that the people in charge did not want to enforce the law and did not care about its effects on American communities. Crime wasn’t about the official crime rates, but about the feeling that the people in charge were more interested in soft justice for criminals than security for law-abiding citizens.
In all these cases, the country’s political elite, both national and local, appeared heedless, if not contemptuous, of the concerns of the people they’re supposed to look out for. This only further deepened the alienation everyday people — especially working men from all racial and ethnic backgrounds — felt from an elite caste that appeared more interested in moral preening than real leadership.
The system wasn’t working for them, and worse, no one seemed to care about or for them. And so they voted for the one person who could credibly threaten to blow the whole thing to smithereens.
An incomplete revolution?
The 2016 election could have been the aberration many expected it to be, if the ruling class — largely represented by the Democratic Party — had tried to engage the people who had rejected them, rather than ostracize them.
Instead, it called them fascists, and so the revolutionary spirit has spread. And it could go much further.
Millions more Americans feel equally alienated from their political leadership, each for his or her own reasons, but couldn’t abide Donald Trump and his movement — yet. They could easily be pushed toward him or his successor if the country’s liberal establishment doesn’t learn the right lesson.
That lesson? America is a democracy, and the people will only tolerate rule by a sneering self-appointed noble class for so long.
Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “Why Donald Trump will win.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.