Allegheny County Executive Sara Innamorato was always going to have to raise taxes. So would Joe Rockey, had he prevailed last November. For that matter, so would Rich Fitzgerald, had he been allowed to stay on for a fourth term.
That’s because property tax revenues plateaued and are now declining, due to shocks to the commercial real estate market and the county’s asinine system of ad hoc property reassessments. It’s also because Mr. Fitzgerald managed to hold the line on taxes because of federal pandemic relief funds, which are now expiring.
Whether she has to raise county property taxes by a full 2.2 mils, or 46.5%, is another matter. I can’t help but admire the boldness — a quality in short supply among Pittsburgh’s current leadership class — but the line between boldness and recklessness is a fine one. And in the case of raising revenue on the backs of taxpayers, it’s all a matter of how you sell it.
Blame game
As an elected official, there are two ways to handle broad-based tax hikes: either blame someone else, or own it yourself. As of yet, Ms. Innamorato hasn’t fully committed to either — but she’ll have to if she wants not only to muster 10 of 15 votes on county council, but survive the ordeal politically intact.
There is a plausible, if ultimately somewhat unfair, case for blaming someone else. Ms. Innamorato gestured in this direction when she said during her budget address to council that “the previous administration could have chosen a path of more incremental increases.”
But despite the former county executive’s unpopularity among Ms. Innamorato’s progressive base, Mr. Fitzgerald remains broadly appreciated in the wider electorate — and, in terms of media, at least as visible as his successor. Turning her tax hike into a referendum on him would be imprudent.
More than that, Ms. Innamorato closed this door in her first week in office, when she made a splashy announcement of generous raises for non-union county employees. This tax increase has nothing to do with those raises, which were at least in part funded in the budget passed last year. But if a tax increase was coming — and anyone who knew anything about county government knew that it was — then it was essential to prepare the public by signaling austerity, not profligacy.
The raises were the kind of decision you make when times are good; now, suddenly, Ms. Innamorato is revealing to the vast majority of people who don’t know anything about county government that times are actually bad.
Sales pitch
Which means she’s left with one way forward: own the tax hike. That entails promising taxpayers precise benefits that are part of a coherent vision — and then delivering. It’s one of the hardest jobs in public leadership, requiring tireless on-message communications with the public, followed by competent execution of a multifaceted plan of action.
Right now, unfortunately, the vision is airy and the public details are scarce. Ms. Innamorato’s slogan, “a county for all,” gives people a vague sense of her priorities, but it won’t get it done on its own. In her budget address, she did discuss county services such as mitigating homelessness, improving the jail and shoring up the Kane centers for the elderly and other adults who require specialized care — but without specifics about what this tax hike would fund.
The county executive also referenced 91 priorities that came out of the Allegheny For All survey. This is far too many issues for anybody to keep straight. I’d suggest more like three, or five at most, along with precise information about how paying more in taxes will benefit taxpayers. And Ms. Innamorato and her surrogates should be repeating these benefits on every radio and television station in town, not to mention in print interviews, every day.
At least some of these details exist — I’ve seen them — but they haven’t been centered in a public sales pitch. Skeptical and critical voices have filled the void, leaving Ms. Innamorato looking aloof.
High stakes
While there’s still time for the county executive to make her case, week one has given the impression that she might not appreciate the stakes — for her, for county council, for taxpayers and even for the presidential election.
For Ms. Innamorato herself, this is a moment to demonstrate her seriousness and to burnish her salesmanship skills in advance of the even-more-contentious reassessment battle to come. She cannot afford to go into that moment appearing weak.
For members of council, they are more likely to be punished at election time if their constituents don’t understand why they’re being asked to cough up more money, and what they’re going to get for it.
For taxpayers, while an increase of less than $20 a month for the median homeowner is modest, it mustn’t be dismissed: For many people it will be a real sacrifice, and for many others it will be much more than $20 a month.
And then there’s the election. In this battleground of battlegrounds, Ms. Innamorato has a chance to make Democratic governance look serious and forward-looking, or profligate and heedless. There’s nothing she could have done about the timing of her proposal — the budget address is set for autumn — but she can determine how it will land. How well she succeeds could reverberate for years to come.
Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “Why Donald Trump benefits from chaos.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.