I don’t think anyone else in Pittsburgh could have convened the crowd Jim Roddey convened on Wednesday, nearly three months after his death. It’s a fitting tribute to the first Allegheny County Executive — and a credit to the event’s lead organizer, Pitt Chancellor Emeritus Mark Nordenberg — that Mr. Roddey’s memorial service was the most complete public assembly of the region’s leadership in years.

It would be obnoxious, and I would soon run out of column inches, if I were to list the dignitaries in attendance at Pitt’s Alumni Hall that afternoon. But to give a sense of it: Candidates and elected officials of both parties who had run against one another, are currently running against one another or may soon run against one another mingled in shared appreciation of Mr. Roddey’s life and legacy. Every Allegheny County Executive celebrated their Republican forebear.

Suburban conservatives and city liberals under one roof. Business leaders. Foundation officials. To his credit, the Mayor.

In a time of intense — and often well-earned — suspicion of established norms and institutions, it’s important to remember that these kinds of gatherings are essential to a healthy, cooperative civic order. It would be good, for all of us, if they happened more often.

Advertise with us

A matter of trust

Mr. Roddey understood that relationships are everything, and that includes relations among civic leaders, including across the aisle.

Now, fostering “relationships” among the political elite often suggests smoke-filled backrooms, quid pro quos, a conspiracy against the common man. There’s no doubt that political networks that become closed and insulated from public responsibility incentivize self-dealing. Self-serving “relationships,” whether on K Street in D.C. or Grant Street in Pittsburgh, are in part how civic trust was so destroyed that Americans may be poised to elect Donald Trump president, again.

But abusus non tollit usum — abuse of a thing doesn’t cancel out its legitimate uses. And the truth is civic leaders, elected and unelected, need a sphere of intimacy, at least somewhat free from public political pressures, where they can build trust among themselves. In a political system like ours, which intentionally creates friction by setting disparate interests against one another, leaders need to be able to trust one another to get anything done — for the people.

In other words, for leaders to have a healthy relationship with the people they serve, they need to have healthy relationships with one another, across partisan and ideological divides.

Missing middle

But unfortunately, political events have been largely bifurcated into public spectacles and private pay-to-play receptions. The former — town halls and the like — have their place, but they are performances, and are rarely genuinely productive. The latter — fundraisers and so on — also have their place, but they bring like people and interests together, and of course are exclusive and often secretive.

Advertise with us

There is a missing middle, for events that are semi-official and semi-public. At Wednesday’s event, a remarkably comprehensive group of civic leaders were not just together, but together in a (more or less) public setting and (more or less) at ease. Yes, there were tensions in the room, but they were muted by the shared purpose of honoring Mr. Roddey and, by extension, the value of public service.

In decades past, the strength of public-private collaboration saved Pittsburgh from a worse fate after industrial collapse, but those civic muscles have since atrophied. The personal energy that went into the work has dissipated; the structures and wisdom that made it possible have not been passed down intact; and a new cohort of leaders appear to lack the knowledge (and often the skill and even the will) to strengthen the sinews of civic collaboration once again.

Wednesday’s event gave me hope. It was an environment that broke down barriers, and provided a unique opportunity to build relationships. And it planted an idea in my head — call it the Roddey Circuit.

Extending the legacy

The Roddey Circuit would be a series of events convened by a neutral institution, like a university (or a newspaper). Each would have a particular policy agenda — say, economic development or fostering the arts — with a regional focus to ensure Republican and Democratic participation. But the primary purpose would be conviviality.

There would be speakers, a mix of experts and stakeholders and, above all, interesting people that would make important people want to be there, which would make slightly less important people feel they need to be there. There would be food and drink, and time and space to enjoy them. Participation would be by invitation and word of mouth, and media would be welcome: semi-official and semi-public.

Advertise with us

One of Kipling’s melodic descriptions of greatness went like this: “If you can force your heart and nerve and sinew / To serve your turn long after they are gone.” Jim Roddey’s memorial service proved he had achieved just that, perhaps even catalyzing a rebirth of pragmatism and collaboration.

Now the leaders of the region he served so well can extend that legacy even further into the future.

Brandon McGinley is the editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: bmcginley@post-gazette.com.