The story made international news last August: A Dauphin County woman took a nearly four-hour Lyft ride to Kennedy Township, then sprayed bullets at the foster family caring for her biological 2-year-old son. Mercifully no one was hurt, and the assailant was quickly subdued.

I only found out later that I knew the parents in question. In fact, I had helped craft their application for their first adoption, several years earlier.

Their names are Bob and Caitlyn Waruszewski, and this is their story.

A fateful moment

The Waruszewskis had always dreamed of having a big family, but fertility struggles put those dreams into doubt. After their daughter, Lucy, was born, further medical complications dashed their hopes for the life they had planned for.

Advertise with us

But the dream did not go away. After a period of reflection, the Waruszewskis began the process of adoption. Their goal was to provide a loving home for young children whose parents could not take care of them.

Gracie, now 5, came first. Then Eddie, now 4. Then in 2021, the Waruszewskis learned that Gracie’s biological father had another child, Cato, with another woman. When possible, it’s considered best practice to keep even half-siblings united, so the family became the top candidate for a permanent placement.

While the Waruszewskis were accustomed to hard cases, this one brought a special, and deeply worrying, complication: Cato’s mother, Kayla Menne, had made violent threats against her own son and his first foster family.

The Kennedy Township family seemed like a perfect solution: They were hundreds of miles away from Ms. Menne and had already adopted Cato’s half-sister. Dauphin County Children and Youth Services promised all identifying information about the Waruszewskis would be redacted throughout the process, and told the family not to reveal anything about themselves to Ms. Menne during the hearings that would formalize the arrangement.

But the message never made it to the magistrate who oversaw one early proceeding. Over Zoom, with Ms. Menne watching, the judge told the family to state and to spell their names for the record. CYS officials attempted to intervene, but the judge insisted. Bob and Caitlyn froze, then complied, not wanting to do anything to jeopardize the placement. But they feared that moment might jeopardize their entire family.

Advertise with us

And they were right.

Innocence destroyed

On Aug. 7, 2023, Ms. Menne followed through on her delusional drive to try to kill her son. She took a rideshare from Harrisburg, during which she had several hours to contemplate her decision. She emerged on a residential street in Kennedy, where Mr. Waruszewski was taking the four children for a walk, and started shooting.

The father was holding Cato and ran behind a parked car. The mother came careening out of the house to intercept the gunman. Toddler Eddie was across the street and hid behind a neighbor. Lucy and Gracie scootered away as fast as they could.

In the end, Ms. Menne had emptied a clip in the direction of the Waruszewski family and their home — including point blank at the neighbor protecting Eddie, Duane Mrazek — but hit no one. The parents and the neighbor subdued her until the police arrived.

As harrowing as those minutes were, the stories of the aftermath contained in the parents’ victim statements — which will be read at a bench trial set to begin on Monday — may be worse.

Advertise with us

“Life is nearly unbearable,” Caitlyn writes. “Every day, I feel like I am drowning, with no end in sight. I now experience panic attacks, crippling anxiety, and depression that has inhibited my ability to care for my children.”

Each of the Waruszewskis’ adopted children has experienced major setbacks in coping with their developmental deficits. Years of progress achieved through various forms of therapy was wiped out. Eddie, only 4, has been diagnosed with PTSD.

Nine months later, none of the children sleep well, which means their parents don’t, either. There is a constant unease in the family home now, and everyone is quicker to frustration, to anger and to tears than they were before. In opening their home to children who had suffered trauma from an early age, the family had aimed to provide a sanctuary. It has been permanently shattered.

The new asylums

The twenty-first century American justice and health care systems aren’t set up to handle people like Kayla Menne. Through multiple involuntary psychiatric commitments, she has never relented in her obsession with hurting her biological children and those who care for them. At the hearing that terminated her parental rights, the judge described her as a “sociopath” and ordered that she never have contact with her son, Cato, again.

She had ended her relationship with her parents in a written message with the kind of intentional infliction of emotional pain, and the threat of physical harm, that merits the word “diabolical.” They, too, fear her release.

Advertise with us

Some people cannot be helped, cannot be restored and cannot be trusted to live freely in society. This is uncomfortable to say, but anyone who has encountered such a person knows it to be true.

In the past, this reality would have been frankly acknowledged, which is in part why state hospital systems exist. The abuses that took place within those systems are legendary: torture, experiments, extrajudicial imprisonment, not to mention hiding away people with disabilities who could have thrived with community-based care.

But these horrors obscure the fact that state hospitals were originally a progressive measure, championed by reformers like Dorothea Dix — for whom Dixmont State Hospital, formerly on a bluff above Ohio River Blvd, was named. They filled a need for long-term inpatient mental health care that was otherwise not being met.

In the 1960s, a new generation of reformers began dismantling the old institutions in favor of community-based care models, which mostly never came on-line. So in Pennsylvania, there are only two state hospitals left — Torrance in Westmoreland County and Norristown in Montgomery County — and the wait for beds is years long. Last year, an inmate waiting for space at Torrance died in the Allegheny County Jail, which is notoriously operating with zero mental health therapists.

Indeed, jails and prisons have become the successors to the asylums. Rather than replacing the institutional mental health system with something better, we have gone backwards to the pre-Dix era. And while names like Mayview and Dixmont have come to evoke horror and disgust, people who know both systems say candidly, if quietly: They were better than jail.

Advertise with us

But jail is the only option for Kayla Menne. And that presents a problem for real justice, for everyone.

Zero-sum justice

The Waruszewskis tell me that, as Catholics, they believe deeply in the power and importance of mercy. Now they are in the awful position of weighing the emotional security and physical safety of their family against that belief. It raises some of the most difficult questions of all. What is mercy? What is justice?

The family finds itself taking an uncomfortable but necessary position: Ms. Menne must remain locked up for as long as possible — or at least until 3-year-old Cato is an adult and capable of defending himself. Mercy for him, and for their entire family, comes first. Justice begins with protecting the innocent.

“I want to be able to let my kids play outside and not worry,” Bob tells me. It’s a case where there is a direct correlation: Freedom and mercy for the defendant means the destruction of freedom and mercy for the innocent victims.

But Ms. Menne’s crimes, as far as the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania is concerned, do not merit the kind of permanent or semi-permanent exclusion that would allow her victims to live in peace. For the seven counts each of aggravated assault, simple assault and reckless endangerment, plus firearms offenses, she might receive about 20 years — but only if the judge takes the very unusual step of stacking all the sentences consecutively. A more typical concurrent sentence might be closer to two years.

Advertise with us

The judge can’t just throw out the sentencing guidelines, and the state can’t legally stick Ms. Menne in Torrance forever — and there isn’t space even if it could.

That means that, at some point, she will be free, and the Waruszewski family will not.

True mercy

There is no going back to the peace the family enjoyed before last Aug. 7. They dream about guns and bullets and the “scary lady” who tried to kill them all. That will never end, because they were failed by a system that was supposed to protect them.

And now they’re faced with another system that isn’t equipped to protect them. The best they can hope and pray for is this: that the moment when little Cato and his family will have to fear for their lives again can be put off as far as possible into the future.

That’s what real justice demands. That’s what real mercy demands.

Brandon McGinley is the editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: bmcginley@post-gazette.com.