You can imagine the campaign ads now: “When greedy developers tried to flood Larimer with luxury apartments, Mayor Ed Gainey forced them to include more places for regular Pittsburghers. Ed Gainey: fighting for us.”

In reality, Mr. Gainey’s intervention into Walnut Capital’s Bakery Square expansion shows everything wrong with his administration’s approach to “affordable housing.” In order to score 80 mostly one-bedroom “affordable” apartments in Penn Ave high-rises, he scuttled an agreement with Larimer’s own community organization that promised 100 for-sale single-family homes in the heart of the neighborhood.

“Affordable housing” as practiced in Pittsburgh is a sham.

Hammer and nail

It’s undeniable that, despite having some of the least expensive housing in America, the market in Pittsburgh is still mismatched with the means of everyday people.

Advertise with us

Yet time and again Pittsburgh’s leaders have reached for a single tool in the housing affordability policy kit: rental units discounted by fiat for low-income residents. It’s the simplest and bluntest tool at hand, and the most politically satisfying. But it isn’t working.

These unfunded mandates, while well-intentioned, significantly shift financial incentives against residential development. After only two years, the editorial board of the Philadelphia Inquirer has turned against that city’s “inclusionary zoning” ordinance, which designates neighborhoods where 20% of units in new developments must be “affordable.” The predictable result: Very little building has occurred in those neighborhoods, worsening the housing crunch.

Pittsburgh’s copycat law, heralded as a historic victory for the people when it passed, has already stifled development. The bid to replace the old ShurSave grocery store in Bloomfield with apartments provoked legitimate concerns from neighbors, and was turned away by the Zoning Board of Adjustment, for its size and scope. But at least some of that was forced by the requirement to reserve 10% of units at 50% area median income in an awful economic environment for building.

In Pittsburgh as in Philadelphia, 10% of zero is zero.

Level-headed

The Bakery Square debacle, however, points to a deeper problem with Pittsburgh’s “affordable housing” mania: Income-restricted rentals, whether in luxury high-rises or modest townhomes, do not build sustainable communities. That requires home ownership.

Advertise with us

The original deal among Walnut Capital, the Larimer Consensus Group and the Village Collaborative of East Liberty, brokered by former councilman Rev. Ricky Burgess, was inspired. Rather than emphasizing income-restricted rentals in buildings otherwise marketed for cash-flush tech workers, the community benefits agreement stipulated that the developer would pitch in $6 million to launch a $25 million fund, filled out by foundation and corporate donors, to build 100 for-sale homes in the heart of Larimer.

The project was likely to be completed in association with Level, an affordable housing developer that leverages grant money to build handsome homes it sells to qualifying buyers at steep discounts. The properties have a 10-year deed restriction, so you can’t buy a house for $100,000 and immediately flip it for $400,000. But after that decade, you have full control (pending remaining mortgage payments) of an asset that can be the foundation of generational wealth.

The Larimer vision? Rebuild the diverse mixed-income community that had thrived there in decades past. That means some affordable rentals, yes, but also affordable starter homes and homes to grow a family in. That means thinking big and working hard, not just slapping “15% at 80% AMI” on a press release and calling it a day.

But that’s all anyone in city government wants to do.

It’s a trap

Income-restricted rentals, on their own, don’t create wealth or sustain communities. In fact, they can limit wealth and smother communities.

Advertise with us

Consider a family of three that makes $45,000 a year and lives in an “affordable” unit pegged to 50% of area median income. For that family size in Pittsburgh, $45,200 is the income limit to quality for 50% AMI housing. That means a raise to $46,000 would lead to an increase in rent much higher than the raise itself, which might chase the family out of their home.

In other words, “affordable housing” that’s limited to income-restricted rentals both traps low-income families in that status and induces transiency. Neither of these lead to flourishing and sustainable communities.

An exclusive focus on income-restricted rentals — especially shoehorning them into luxury complexes — also fails to address the most serious housing affordability problem in Pittsburgh: affordability for families with, or planning for, children. While building housing of all kinds — even those “luxury lofts” — applies some downward price pressure to the market, the housing market is also segmented. Subsidizing affordable one-bedroom apartments does little to improve the market for three-bedroom houses, which is where the affordability problem really chases the next generation out of the city.

The Bakery Square-Larimer community benefits agreement should have been an easy win for the Gainey administration. It represented the kind of thoughtful, mature economic development the city should be striving for. And it was what the community wanted, because it’s what the community needs.

But it wasn’t what Ed Gainey wanted. It didn’t have his personal stamp on it. It didn’t make for a great campaign ad.

Advertise with us

So, once again, Pittsburgh is stuck with “affordable housing” — at the expense of affordable homes.

Brandon McGinley is the editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: bmcginley@post-gazette.com.