The leader of a minority party forms a coalition and wins an election that ousts the plurality party in power. He immediately fires the leadership of a crucial state agency to remove his predecessor’s influence. Amid public protests from the previous ruling party, the police take over the agency’s headquarters.
Both the new leader and the old claim to be defending democracy and the rule of law. Who is right?
What if I told you this story comes from a (mostly) stable European state; the previous ruling party was broadly right-wing and nationalist; and the successor is a coalition of the center and left? And they were fighting for control of the state media?
You’ve probably decided, haven’t you, which side is really defending democracy, and which had been or is now undemocratically trying to form state institutions in its own image? Which is good, and which is bad? Which is a friend doing what it must, and which is an enemy who must be driven out?
Each side thinks it’s right
By their own lights, each side has a claim to be correct. The right says the country’s news media has a persistent left-wing bias, and under its leadership the state agency reflected the people’s wishes for balance, as expressed at the polls. The new government says it is restoring impartiality after the undemocratic capture of state media.
But when the stakes are thought to be the future of democratic governance itself, understanding the other side is out. And total victory is in.
Read More
I offer this sketch — very roughly based on current events in Poland — as a Rorschach test that demonstrates how in democratic societies, what counts as “democratic” isn’t always obvious, and usually depends on each person’s ideological presuppositions.
It’s not hard to see comparisons to our own upcoming elections, where it has become popular to say that democracy itself is on the ballot.
While this is a Democratic talking point deployed against former President Donald Trump, what many people who use this language don’t fully understand is that Mr. Trump’s supporters — especially those most dedicated to the MAGA cause — completely agree. They just disagree about where the threat to democracy is coming from.
Understanding MAGA
If you polled the people who marched to the Capitol on Jan. 6, 2021, very few if any would have claimed they were there to subvert democracy. They would have said they were there to preserve it.
In fact, an honest commitment to American democracy is the best explanation for the endurance of Mr. Trump’s popularity. His supporters think he was unfairly denied victory in 2020 — as undemocratic an action as it’s possible to imagine — and as a matter of justice and democratic principles he deserves another crack at the establishment that foiled him.
Many, if not most, don’t have a particular theory of the election heist — but they did see every node of American power, from the media to big tech to high business, line up against the sitting president. And they feel that was dirty pool.
They feel that was undemocratic.
It’s hard to overstate how important it is to understand this aspect of the MAGA movement. First of all, it’s good in itself to understand and to take seriously the political motivations of tens of millions of fellow citizens, so they aren’t reduced in one’s mind to hordes of sub-rational orcs preparing to pillage American institutions.
But even more importantly for the coming tense election season, it’s essential to understand that very often the gravest threat to democratic norms comes from overzealous attempts to protect democracy, especially from apparent internal enemies.
If there is a real political crisis in the next 12 months, it won’t be the election itself, but the reaction to the election. If Mr. Trump loses, his supporters may despair that the country’s elite can once again conspire to thwart the people’s true tribune, and seek to assert themselves in ways more coherent and destructive than Jan. 6.
If Mr. Trump wins, his opponents may despair that a man who has shown such contempt for democratic norms and procedures has been chosen once again, and seek to restrain him from ascending to the office or using even its legitimate powers — contingencies that are openly discussed.
In either case, the justification will be the same: protecting democracy. And the question will be: How much damage are we willing to do to it, in order to save it?
Hatred and adulation
It is a symptom of terrible social distrust and alienation, and a cause of frightening political instability, when the people feel the country’s very foundation is at stake at every election.
Indeed, it is a structural weakness of all democratic systems that the fate of democracy itself is a weight too great for democratic procedures to bear. Economic policy, foreign policy, even contentious social policy — these are the issues democratic procedures are meant to settle, or at least to sublimate, for a time.
There are no democratic defense mechanisms for when a critical mass of people believe democratic procedures have stopped producing democratic results — whether than means electing a demagogue, literally from the Greek for “people-leader,” or thwarting one.
And yet — and yet — if there’s one lesson Americans should have learned from 2016, 2020 and everything in between, it’s that our political system can absorb a tremendous amount of stress. Unfortunately, rather than instilling confidence, this seems only to have heightened the anxiety about what will happen next time.
I fear these anxious obsessions about the future of democracy will become a self-fulfilling prophecy, when this year’s elections can and should be contested on less volatile ground. I believe the system can and will survive whatever happens, unless we dismantle it ourselves out of fear or despair.
And I think that if Donald Trump is remembered as America’s breaking point, it won’t be his own actions, but what he inspires in others — hatred and adulation — that brings us there.
Brandon McGinley is the editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: bmcginley@post-gazette.com.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.