When my father grew up in Sheraden in the 1950s and 1960s, Holy Innocents Church was the center of life. It was one of those neighborhood parishes, numerous in those days, with enough children to have its own high school. Christmas midnight Mass in this gothic wonder was the social event of the season.

Holy Innocents began from Crafton’s St. Philip, the mother church of the West End, in 1924. Sheraden natives point to St. Philip’s next progeny, Ascension in Crafton in 1970, as a turning point: The overambitious expansion began to drain the vigor from Holy Innocents. In 2016, my father’s childhood parish closed.

I visited Holy Innocents this week for the first time in many years, because I’d found out that a curious institution had filled the void left by the congregation: a free museum dedicated to historic documents. How I made this discovery, however, is discouraging.

To fulfill a campaign promise to extract support for city government from enormous nonprofits, especially UPMC, early this year Mayor Ed Gainey directed his Law and Finance departments to examine every parcel of tax exempt land to ensure its purpose meets the state’s definition of charitable. The first tranche of challenges, announced this March, included the Sheraden museum.

Advertise with us

While there is little chance the challenge will succeed — and seemingly little interest in pressing the claim on the part of the city — the move shows the amateurish and scattershot nature of a policy doomed to failure.

Handwritten history

The Karpeles Manuscript Library Museum system was founded in the 1980s by the late mathematician and businessman David Karpeles of Santa Barbara, Calif. Along with his wife Marsha, Karpeles had collected historic documents — maps, music, letters, folios — and eventually decided everyday people should have access to the wonders of history. The free museums he founded are in off-the-beaten-path locations, including Duluth, Minn., Alvin, Texas, Buffalo, N.Y., and Sheraden.

In an age of security and surveillance, the museum recalls a time of openness and trust. The door is swung wide open: Passersby can see from the sidewalk the modest display cases holding remarkable artifacts.

The organization cycles its million-piece collection through its ten museums, so the exhibits don’t go stagnant. In mid-September, Holy Innocents had just received, fittingly, a variety of religious texts, most notably pages from an original Gutenberg (1450s) and King James Version (1610s) Bible.

Advertise with us

The front of the church, however, had been given a nautical theme. Artifacts included Horatio Nelson’s handwritten instructions for the 1805 Battle of Trafalgar; orders signed by Elizabeth I of England and Philip II of Spain for the 1588 confrontation of the Spanish Armada; and a 1502–3 report on the East Coast of America in the hand of Christopher Columbus.

These original hand-produced documents provide a personal connection with the greatest people and moments of history that no other artifact can match. The museum, which also brings reproductions into area schools, is a treasure.

Profane but not sordid

When the Catholic Church decommissions a church building, the legalese reads that it is relegated to “profane but not sordid use.” The word “profane” simply means “not sacred” — in other words, the building is free to be used for purposes other than worship.

“Sordid,” on the other hand, describes those reuses that are anti-sacred, directly contradicting the structure’s original purpose. The intentionally sacrilegious Altar Bar, now closed, in the old St. Elizabeth Church in the Strip District is the paradigmatic example.

Advertise with us

The second act of Holy Innocents is about as close to dignified as can be hoped for today. That’s certainly what Clarise Pryor, a middle-aged Black woman from Manchester, thought when she stumbled onto the museum on Thursday afternoon.

She told me she was only in the neighborhood to visit a nearby school, and popped into the church-museum to charge her phone. When she realized what she had discovered, she used that phone to photograph several displays so she could read and learn about them later.

When I caught up with her afterward, the word she kept using was “phenomenal.” In her neighborhood, she said, several old churches were crumbling, but here in Sheraden this one was in good repair and remained a community asset. She raised her hand over the church in a kind of blessing and said, simply, “Stay!”

Caught in the crossfire

Dominic Woods is the Pittsburgh Karpeles Manuscript Library Museum’s director, a teacher at Brashear High School and a very generous man. He refused to criticize the mayor who is, on paper, trying to drive the museum out of the city, accepting without complaint that it’s caught in the crossfire between the Gainey administration and UPMC.

Advertise with us

I am not obliged to be so generous. If the city picked tax-exempt properties to challenge at random, then it is acting in bad faith. And the March press release announcing the challenges, in which Mr. Gainey stated that “already the Law and Finance departments have identified properties that are not paying their fair share” — including the Karpeles Museum — was simply a lie.

If, on the other hand, challenging the museum was the product of real study, then those departments are incompetent. A free museum of artifacts is a pristine example of a “purely public charity” under state law.

Either possibility leads to the same conclusion: The project to stymy UPMC and other nonprofits by challenging the tax-exempt status of individual properties is a gong show. No effort that catches this museum in its dragnet has the credibility to threaten multibillion-dollar institutions.

When I told Ms. Pryor about the challenge, she couldn’t understand why the city would hassle the museum she had just discovered. She had been so taken by the building and the surrounding neighborhood that she began looking at houses on Landis Street. In front of that gothic landmark, still anchoring the community in a new way after 99 years, she pleaded, “Leave them alone!”

Brandon McGinley is the deputy editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: bmcginley@post-gazette.com.