H. L. Mencken famously described Puritanism as “the haunting fear that someone, somewhere, might be happy.” Allow me to adapt that to the anti-development so-called progressivism that is currently ascendant in Pittsburgh: It’s the haunting fear that someone, somewhere, might be making money.
Now, I’d be among the first to argue that the private profit motive is a poor guide to the public good. What is best for a developer’s balance sheet may be good for the city’s tax revenue — unless that’s been offset by generous tax incentives — but is only incidentally good for the community at large. That is, a developer can thrive while the community in which it operates, taken as a whole, does not.
What I deny, however, is the emerging dogma that a developer’s success is intrinsically suspicious — that big builders are to be opposed precisely because of their proven ability to build. This conviction, purely ideological and detached from the observable benefits of many projects, leads commentators and policymakers to refuse even to consider the virtues and drawbacks of particular developments.
Instead, like Monty Python’s incompetent cheesemonger, there is nothing but “no.”
The ghost of ‘urban renewal’
Every planned project in Pittsburgh, especially those in or near majority-minority neighborhoods, lives in the shadow of the destruction of the Lower Hill District. The 50s- and 60s-era mania for “renewal” — a thinly veiled euphemism for racist expulsions and the razing of vibrant, if low-income, communities — reached its apogee in a planned “cultural acropolis” overlooking the Golden Triangle that ended as a hockey arena and plains of painted asphalt.
Read More
It is an irony of today’s anti-development reaction that its main proponents — activists and social media obsessives whose approval is coveted by the Mayor’s office — were not yet born when the Hill was scoured. Indeed, many of their parents weren’t yet alive, either.
But the memory has been passed down, and the scars are still visible. The angst over gentrification in East Liberty, where many Lower Hill residents were herded like animals onto very ugly arks, is an aftershock of the “urban renewal” debacle of two generations ago. In fact, it’s not hard to imagine that the very same people displaced from the Hill, or their descendants, have now been displaced from East Liberty.
The social and physical destruction of the Hill counsels skepticism of big plans that might impinge on the lives and livelihoods of people who’ve historically been considered impediments to development, rather than its intended beneficiaries. But it is possible to go too far, to be gripped by fear and self-righteousness to the point that all growth is smothered. And that is the reigning attitude in Pittsburgh right now.
Equal protection
A popular response among Pittsburgh’s progressive bien pensants to last Sunday’s Post-Gazette editorial, which revealed the City Planning office’s law-skirting obstruction of Walnut Capital’s bid to expand its Bakery Square district, was, in effect, “Good. Walnut Capital deserves to be obstructed.”
This attitude was basically affirmed by Jake Pawlak, the director of the Office and Management and Budget to which City Planning now reports. Mr. Pawlak took to Twitter not only to defend Zoning Administrator Corey Layman, whom the editorial had identified as the official suspiciously holding up Walnut’s applications, but to swipe the developer for “demanding special treatment.” What that special treatment might be is anybody’s guess, but for an audience predisposed to be suspicious, the insinuation is all that mattered.
Besides Mr. Pawlak’s public statements, all the whispers emanating from City Hall indicate the Post-Gazette’s scrutiny has hardened the administration’s resolve to check Walnut Capital’s plans. If the developer has failed to fulfill any of its own legal obligations — and there is no evidence it has — or if its plans fail to fulfill the legally prescribed criteria, then this is right and just. But if the administration is signaling its intention to twist or ignore the law because Walnut is disfavored, or to punish it for the scrutiny the process has received, then it is abusing its power.
If mayors can choose to apply the law in different ways to different people and institutions based on their degree of favor, then everyone from citizens to other developers and corporations should take note: That means the law protects no one at all.
The cost of ‘no’
The cost of anti-development dogma is difficult to notice and to calculate, because it is an absence. “What might have been” is hard to conceptualize, and is completely invisible in daily life. The site of the proposed Bakery Square expansion can continue to be a mediocre shopping center — and a wide field of surface parking that violates every principle of good urban design — more or less indefinitely. And few people will care.
Stagnation is easy. But it is not costless.
The technical term for that shopping-center land on the city’s zoning map is “Highway Commercial” — a suburban designation at the heart of one of the densest sectors of the city. It is nonsensical to believe that defending this status quo, almost certainly an accommodation to a previous generation of developers, is any meaningful sense “progressive.”
If there were some other proposal on the table for this land, or for the scuttled Oakland Crossings development, or for other stagnant parcels across the city, the argument for delays and denials might hold some water. Holding out for a perfectly diverse, perfectly inclusive, perfectly affordable development, however, will result in nothing happening, ever.
Sometimes, it seems like that’s the point. If nothing happens, there’s no blame for something going wrong, or for someone not getting his cut. If nothing happens, there’s no hard work to make the something the best thing it can be. If nothing happens, there’s no risk.
Except the risk of managed decline, which for a brief moment this city seemed to have escaped. But no longer.
Brandon McGinley is the deputy editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: bmcginley@post-gazette.com.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.