While shots were still being fired in Garfield on August 23, a narrative emerged among the activists and anonymous (and seemingly unoccupied) zealots who dominate social media discourse about — and disproportionately influence — Pittsburgh politics: William Hardison Jr., the squatter who opened fire on sheriff’s deputies sent to evict him and eventually blasted hundreds of rounds into the streets, was a victim of a violently racist and classist system that denied him a home, to which he had a right, out of pure greed. Open and shut.

As facts emerged over the course of the day that complicated this narrative — most significantly, that Hardison held fringe anti-government “sovereign citizen” beliefs that essentially excluded himself from society — the orthodoxy only hardened. Anyone who suggested the issue was more complex than “affordable housing,” a phrase which has become an incantation meant to solve all social problems, was hounded as a capitalist (and probably racist) toad.

One popular left-wing Twitter/​X account, which had wisely warned fellow progressives to be careful with housing policy “hot takes,” had gone private by the end of the day to avoid the resulting abuse. When the account re-emerged in a few days, the offending tweet had been deleted. It was precisely the fact the person had been proved correct that meant she had to be punished.

People not pawns

Advertise with us

The conceit of aggressively progressive social media personalities — and increasingly of politicians who speak and act like Twitter accounts come to life — is that they stand up for the humanity of marginalized people, like William Hardison, against an inhuman economic system. But in ignoring the complicated reality of the very people they claim to support, they treat them as two-dimensional cartoon characters, and not really people at all.

The truth is that many of the progressive criticisms of housing policy are basically correct. The commodification of housing — that is to say, treating housing as a financial instrument rather than a human need — has warped the marketplace and our very understanding of “home.” This is exemplified in the increasing number of corporations, like the one that bought Hardison’s shelter at 4817 Broad Street, gobbling up homes as investments.

This is a genuine moral and political problem, and one that conservatives, if they truly value conserving the social fabric, should recognize just as clearly as progressives. But a squatting “sovereign citizen” who believes the law does not apply to him is not an exemplar of this crisis. And treating him like one dangerously oversimplifies not just the Garfield episode, but the problem of housing policy as a whole.

Beyond the law

Mark Twain’s aphorism — “Never let the truth get in the way of a good story” — may be useful for understanding how writers and politicians think, but it’s very bad advice for thinking clearly about public policy.

Advertise with us

The truth is that Hardison’s situation, including 42 citations for violations like driving without a license (because he didn’t recognize the authority of the state to issue licenses), was untenable long before an LLC bought his late brother’s townhome. He would have rejected, and probably did reject, any assistance offered to him. He probably should have been — and I don’t say this lightly, but his beyond-the-law beliefs and behavior made him genuinely dangerous, as the events of August 23 demonstrated — in jail. (Why he wasn’t in jail after so many repeat citations and fines is a question that will need to be answered.)

The idea that Hardison had a right to stay in a home he didn’t own, and never owned, essentially affirms his “sovereign citizen” beliefs. It’s not just a claim about the complex details of housing policy, but a claim that voids the very concepts of law and property. It’s one thing to affirm — as Pittsburgh City Council, in a grandstanding 2021 vote, has done — that housing is a human right. It’s quite another to affirm that any person has a right to any home he decides is his.

That kind of heedless zealotry pushes politics toward extremes and, worse, roots it in unreality. It makes legitimate claims about housing insecurity look ridiculous, and chases away people who might otherwise be open to reform. And it makes solving social and political problems much more difficult.

The right to shelter

After all, it really shouldn’t be controversial to say that society has an obligation to shelter every person. The difficult part, which requires clear thinking grounded in reality, is figuring out how to fulfill that obligation.

Advertise with us

The reason for this duty is simple: A person has a right to the necessities of survival. This idea isn’t modern and secular but ancient and Christian: For most of two millennia it has been a mainstay of moral theology that a person who steals what he needs to survive does not sin, because excess belongs by right to the desperately poor.

But William Hardison didn’t need that home — and his claim to it was based not in necessity but in his bespoke “sovereign citizen” ideology. That ideology forbade him from accepting any other social assistance that might have been offered. While it was a failure at every level to allow Hardison to get to the point where he had barricaded himself inside with an arsenal, once it got there, removing him became necessary.

Whether it required every law enforcement agency except the Postal Police within 100 miles is another matter.

Figuring out how to offer dignified shelter to everyone who wants it is an urgent, but complicated, political problem. Every reform proposal will come with costs to be weighed. Grand statements designed to generate applause rather than solutions, such as U.S. Rep. Summer Lee’s tweet that “gentrification is violent and even deadly,” harden hearts instead of opening minds.

And kneejerk reactions, followed by shamelessly shaming anyone who values the truth over grandstanding zealotry, will only set back the work of building a more humane society.

Brandon McGinley is the deputy editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: bmcginley@post-gazette.com.