The loudest and fastest flyover during a U.S. Air Force Thunderbirds show is a surprise. While audience members are focused on the maneuvers in front of them, the sixth pilot suddenly zooms over their left shoulders at under 1,000 feet and nearly the speed of sound. I turned to my eight-year-old son to see if he was frightened, but his expression was one of pure delight.
It’s a cheeky moment in what is probably one of the most effective domestic propaganda routines in contemporary America. The power of the jet engines — my son indicated that they made his insides shake — and the precision of the pilots are explicitly meant to represent the world-spanning prestige of the United States.
Even the most cynical citizen is forced to conclude, as I did, “yeah, we’re still awesome.”
Freedom and F-16s
This Father’s Day was my first air show, at the Arnold Palmer Airport in Latrobe, which is odd because my father has spent most of his professional life as an aircraft mechanic. As a child I loved visiting his hangar, which felt like a museum or a movie set, and sampling the jelly beans his company’s CEO liked to munch on the corporate jet.
But until a few weeks ago, we had never made it to one of these Top Gun extravaganzas. It was near the end, as the F-16s flexed American firepower while a lilting rendition of God Bless America played over the loudspeaker, that I felt as if I understood my own country for the first time.
That’s a bit of an exaggeration, but it really was the most explicitly I’d experienced the worship of power and the sense of spiritual mission that defines the American soul. God has blessed America with F-16s and freedom, and it would be a dereliction of duty not to use the former to spread the latter.
There’s no question air shows are coded as right-wing events, with the militaria and the guileless patriotism and the celebrations of lethal power ready to strike the bad guys at a moment’s notice. (Though I don’t remember seeing any MAGA attire in Latrobe — a data point for the prognosticators.) It would be a mistake, however, to see the vision of America displayed on the tarmac as a partisan one.
After all, many of the same people who express righteous disdain for Department of Defense-funded stadium flyovers also think the United States should spare no expense in guns and (other people’s) blood not just to defeat but to humiliate Vladimir Putin, and that American power must be deployed to influence the internal affairs of Uganda. The idea that America has a unique spiritual-ideological mission, and must have the power to compel the world to come into our fold, isn’t only a feature of the political right.
What we disagree about is the nature of the mission, and how best to pursue it.
The meaning of America
In a sense, then, the Thunderbirds unwittingly highlight the most fundamental disagreement in American life: What is America for? What’s the purpose of this federation of 50 states, of the people who call them home and of the awesome power of aircraft that can fly three miles straight up into the atmosphere faster than you can order a coffee at Starbucks?
Disputes over this question have been with us from the very beginning, because even before the Founding there was broad agreement that America was for something beyond itself. John Winthrop famously articulated this in 1630 when he used the Biblical image of a “city on a hill” to describe his vision for this new land.
He could not have known then that the elevated beacon of righteousness would one day be an F-16’s afterburner. He also could not have expected that flying a Pride flag at the U.S. Embassy to the Holy See would one day be part of how the nascent nation would understand its purpose.
Even as our differences on the most basic questions of our national integrity are as wide and contentious as ever, the Thunderbirds do offer a point of agreement: They are awesome. A few weeks ago in Latrobe I felt I was witnessing a true high point of human achievement. The power of the engines; the elegance of the motions; the flawless precision of the pilots: We, as Americans and as human beings, can build and achieve great things that seem to approach the realm of fantasy.
And yet, as all the things that divide us continue to show, we remain human. All too human.
Brandon McGinley is the deputy editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: bmcginley@post-gazette.com.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.