I picked up the game of golf from an unusual source. Typically it’s passed down like baseball cards or a preference for Ford over Chevy: father to son. But it was my grandmother, a fan not so much of the game as of Jack Nicklaus personally, who first took me to Cool Springs driving range in Bethel Park, at the age of four.
I took to it pretty well for a preschooler, and by age 8, I was whacking the ball around South Park Golf Course. Around this time, in a reversal of the usual process, my dad bought some clubs so I’d have a partner. While over the years I’ve had the privilege to play some of the region’s storied clubs, like most western Pennsylvania golfers, we’re public course people. These days I’ve come full circle: I rarely have time for anything beyond the South Park nine-hole course we played countless evenings growing up.
Saudi interests
Leon Trotsky reportedly said that even if you’re not interested in war, war is interested in you. That’s basically the relationship between most Americans — these days, especially golfers — and the House of Saud.
There are many perverse aspects of the deal that will merge the PGA Tour with the breakaway Saudi-backed LIV Golf, the most obvious of which is the in-retrospect-obvious fakeness of Tour leadership’s moral dudgeon over LIV’s Saudi “blood money.” Blood, it turns out, does not make money any less valuable, and everyone knew that all along.
But for the average golfer, perhaps one like myself on the cusp of passing down the game to his son, the more painful realization is that even this — even a bucket of balls on a warm summer’s night, or the joy of a made putt or a well-struck drive — is not innocent. Even the little bit of economic activity generated by a gentle passion for a gentle game participates in a system that ends with buying off the world to ignore cruelty and murder.
Read More
Indeed, despite golf’s well-earned reputation as the sport of the elite, most golfers’ stories are more like mine: It’s a lifelong pastime bound up with family memories, not a networking and deal-making stratagem. But what the world of international finance — and specifically the Saudi “sportswashing” Public Investment Fund — recognizes is that it’s a lifelong pastime bound up with family memories that can be monetized.
Everything is an opportunity for profit and plunder. Nothing is pure.
Systems thinking
To be sure, to some degree it’s been this way as long as human beings have made markets. The gold piece you paid for grain eventually financed some bully raiding some lesser bully’s peasants, and so on and so forth.
What’s changed, however, is the nakedness of the system, and the scale on which it operates. Back then, the economic system was decentralized and chaotic. Now, the system is highly centralized, while its global beneficiaries — individuals, corporations, regimes — make no attempt to hide their machinations.
They don’t have to, because they know we won’t — and can’t — stop buying what they’re selling. I’m not going to give up golf, or decline to teach my son the game, because the global professional system is functionally owned by Saudi Arabia. (The new “entity,” whose contours are yet to be decided, will be governed by a majority of PGA Tour executives, but funded primarily by the Saudi regime.) And I’m not going to stop casually following the Tour, because the excellence of the greatest players is astounding and inspiring.
If I denied myself every good thing that’s tainted by nefarious financial interests, I’d never leave my house. Actually, I wouldn’t own a house to leave. Actually, I’d already be dead.
That’s the worst realization of all, that there’s no way to live without the system that encourages and excuses atrocities around the world.
Peace through bullying
I was assigned Thomas L. Friedman’s 2005 paean to globalization, “The World Is Flat,” by a kindly high school history teacher, a member of the last optimistic generation. This was the book where Mr. Friedman revised his “Golden Arches” peace theory about no two countries with McDonald’s coming to blows, which had been immediately blown to bits by the Balkan War. The new version, named for Dell computers, posited that no two counties that shared a complex supply chain would fight each other. Less than a decade later Russia seized Crimea.
Regardless of Mr. Friedman’s spectacular ability to maintain his oracular status while being so often wrong, at the time I thought the book was pretty swell. After all, as a student at a private high school looking forward to an even more private college, I could envision myself as one of the masters of globalization, not one of the billions of left-behinds.
That was always the problem with globalization optimism: We assumed as a matter of course that the United States would drive the values of the global system, and that those values would be good ones. Neither of these assumptions has held, or was ever going to hold.
But the PGA-LIV episode does show that Mr. Friedman was still right that globalization increases the costs of conflict. That’s why the merger happened: The legal conflict between the two organizations was going to become mutually ruinous. Better to cease hostilities than to destroy one another.
It turns out, though, that whoever has deeper pockets and fewer scruples gets to dictate the terms of the peace. Globalization may increase the costs of conflict for the masters of the system, but it also increases the costs of peace, moral and economic, for everyone else.
Faced with a hopelessly cruel world, Voltaire has his hero Candide remark simply, “We must cultivate our garden.” I’m not one to quote the French atheist approvingly, but here his intuitions are right: Let us cultivate the good right around us, rather than obsess over what can’t be helped.
And let us enjoy a beautiful game, while quietly cursing those who see in it nothing but profit and power.
Brandon McGinley is the deputy editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: bmcginley@post-gazette.com.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.