Every week, at least once but usually more than once, our minivan rumbles over the pockmarked pavement of the Robert McAfee Bridge.
I only learned the name of this bridge, just like journalists here and everywhere scrambled to learn the official name of the now-infamous Fern Hollow Bridge, while preparing to write about it. To laymen, it’s the steel structure that carries California Avenue over the Woods Run ravine between Marshall-Shadeland and Brighton Heights.
And it’s falling apart.
The bridge’s deterioration has become a regular topic of conversation among friends who use it, like us, to access our Brighton Heights parish. Some are talking about avoiding the bridge entirely, lest their vehicles finally compromise the crumbling asphalt and rusting steel.
One friend, of a mathematical bent, calculated the realistic chance of going down with the bridge during a weekly passage to be about one in two million. Reassuring. Another friend said he “highly doubts they would risk letting another bridge collapse.”
That, alas, was not as reassuring. Because it’s clear from Fern Hollow — and from one business owner’s experience with the Robert McAfee Bridge — that there is no they. In the city, or state or federal bureaucracies for that matter, there’s no single person or committee who has the agency to ensure that every piece of infrastructure is certainly safe. Rather, there are inspectors and laborers and bureaucrats who each do (more or less) the work they are required to do and file (more or less) the paperwork they are required to file. But does that all add up to the unquestionable integrity of every truss and pipe and retaining wall?
That takes a leap of faith I’m no longer able to make.
I remember when I believed in a they. I’d approach the decrepit Charles Anderson Bridge (Boulevard of the Allies over Panther Hollow) or the precarious McArdle Roadway and tell myself, “They wouldn’t leave this open if it were as structurally unsound as it looks. The problems must be cosmetic. After all, they would know.”
And then the Fern Hollow Bridge showed that obvious structural problems very often are, in fact, obvious structural problems. Rusted out beams. Clogged drains leaving water to carve crevices and dissolve metal. Swiss cheese pavement symptomatic of chronic neglect. These are all visible problems with the Robert McAfee Bridge, as well.
While the National Transportation Safety Board will eventually tell us what went wrong structurally in Frick Park, the city continues to stonewall about its own introspection — if there is any — into where its bureaucratic safeguards failed. Now, when we approach the McAfee, I say a prayer, give the van a little extra gas and hope a fully loaded 13 Bellevue isn’t coming the opposite direction.
As unsettling as the bridge’s deck appears, underneath is downright frightening. Just ask Marcie Kemmler, owner of the iconic Don’s Diner, which stands like a remnant of an ancient civilization amid the weedy pavement of the Woods Run valley.
I visited this past Wednesday with my wife and two youngest children for a hearty breakfast and conversation about the bridge that hovers next to the diner like a rusty Sword of Damocles. Ms. Kemmler told me pieces of metal have been falling off the McAfee Bridge for years; she has collected a box of them, a tiny sample, next to the front door.
The largest piece in her display, about a square foot of ancient corroded steel, landed just a few yards from her. Another much smaller piece whacked her son on the head. And, according to Ms. Kemmler, a “ten-foot pole” crashed just feet from a security guard during the filming of the (aptly named) television show “American Rust.” Oily leakage from the deck, even during dry weather, has stained customers’ cars.
Very often, the city sweeps up the debris — or, she suggests, “the evidence” — by the next day. When it comes to addressing the actual source of the problem, however, Grant Street has not been so assiduous. Her last contact with the office of Mayor Ed Gainey, she says, came last August, when they promised a net would be installed by autumn to catch the debris — a ridiculous stopgap, but better than nothing. But nothing is what she got.
Regular outreach to the office of city councilman Bobby Wilson also proved fruitless, as did my attempt to reach the office. Council redistricting has placed this nook into R. Daniel Lavelle’s district, but Ms. Kemmler has yet to make contact there.
A new burst of promises from the city came after a local television station interviewed Ms. Kemmler and broadcast her collection of rusty rain. This week, the city was to install a fence to keep people and vehicles out of the area immediately underneath the bridge. On Friday, the promise was pushed back to next week. “I’ll believe it when I see it,” Ms. Kemmler says with well-earned cynicism.
Like the Fern Hollow Bridge, the Robert McAfee Bridge has been on an accelerated inspection schedule, with semiannual as opposed to biannual evaluations. Since September 2009, all three main components — the deck, the superstructure that supports the deck and the substructure that supports the whole thing — have been rated “fair.” This has kept the bridge off the top of the priority list, since according to the city’s new Comprehensive Bridge Management Program Report, 32 city-owned structures are rated “poor.”
Ms. Kemmler scoffs at the “fair” designation, and it should be noted that the Fern Hollow Bridge’s substructure was rated “satisfactory” — a step above “fair” — right up to its collapse, despite the complete corrosion and removal of a structural beam. The obvious physical deterioration of the McAfee since 2009 suggests that, at best, it is now on the “poor” side of “fair.”
That’s just a layman’s view, but the observations of passersby proved more predictive than the city’s infrastructure bureaucracy about the Fern Hollow Bridge. I can hope that they, whoever they are, have learned something since. But as long as the city avoids reckoning with its Fern Hollow failure — and acts nonchalantly about this crumbling bridge — hopes and prayers are all I’ll have when I press the pedal to cross the bridge to Mass.
Brandon McGinley is the deputy editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: bmcginley@post-gazette.com.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.