Let’s grant, for the sake of argument, that the now-infamous tweet of Carnegie Mellon professor Uju Anya wishing an “excruciating” death on Queen Elizabeth II for leading a “genocidal empire” expressed the truth, in multiple respects: first, that the late queen was morally responsible for British colonialism and, second, that the tweet represented the true feelings of Ms. Anya.
The former, it should be said, is dubious. Elizabeth presided over the (very) late British Empire the way I preside over my 9-year-old daughter’s tea parties — only ceremonially, and from great distance. But as far as Ms. Anya was concerned, her tweet and its vituperative follow-ups expressed a truth the needed to be said, no matter how unpopular.
The question is: Do the principles of the freedom of speech and academic freedom mean that every true idea is worth expressing at every moment?
When I was more active on social media, I got myself into the most trouble when I asked one question, and one question only, before firing off a tweet or post: “Am I convinced what I am about to say is true?”
Truth, to use the logicians’ language, is a necessary but not sufficient condition to make something worth saying. That is especially true on the internet. It’s the baseline, the bare minimum. If it’s not true, you can’t say it. If it is true, you have to go farther down the decision tree.
Is my idea worth expressing in this way? The same truth can be put into an infinite variety of words. Those words can be gentle and compassionate or shrill and cruel. Sometimes harder words are necessary, but a true statement expressed without charity for others loses something of its truth.
Read More
Is my idea worth expressing in this context? The same truth hits listeners differently depending on what’s going on around them. Breaking sad news to a family member in a private moment on your sofa is appropriate; doing so on a roller coaster probably isn’t. Don’t stand up and announce the Steelers score, true as it may be, during a funeral.
And is my idea worth expressing to this audience? Among close friends, you might express provocative ideas you think are true in order to gauge their response or just for the sake of argument. But on social media your audience is the entire world, and not every idea is ready to be shared with everyone.
For me, after several years, it became clear that almost nothing meaningful I could say on social media met all these conditions. No matter how careful I was, some readers, either honestly or maliciously, heard something different than what I intended — and sometimes my intentions weren’t pure, either. In any case, truth was lost in the medium.
These secondary conditions, which can be distilled into courtesy, are increasingly considered passé. Those like Ms. Anya who specialize in the history and theory of social oppression see standards of courtesy — such as the admonition not to speak ill of the dead — as tools of that oppression. They stifle people who speak truth to power by placing sharp criticisms out of bounds; they prop up the status quo by defining any idea that seriously challenges it as “uncivil” or “discourteous.”
Others are coming to agree with this criticism. They see a social order constrained by a corporate-government-academic alliance for whom courtesy and sensitivity isolate and suffocate challenges, especially on cultural issues, such as gender and race. The only way to make a difference is to overwhelm the system with words and ideas considered to be mean or offensive until it finally breaks down.
The truth is, these criticisms of the secondary conditions of truth-telling are basically correct. Courtesy does protect the status quo. It does place not just cruelties but challenging ideas out of bounds. It does make it harder to effect change.
But that’s not always bad. In fact, it’s necessary. A culture without courtesy would lack one of the very last principles of decency — that is, of treating others with dignity — that holds society together.
Courtesy isn’t costless, it’s true. It constrains our liberty to say and do whatever we’re feeling at any given moment. It slows movements for change, sometimes shamefully, such as during the Civil Rights Era, when it was often considered discourteous to speak plainly about Jim Crow as what it was: American apartheid. In the case of the royal family, it can lead to concealing crimes and protecting predators. There are times and places where the veil of civility completely obscures the truth, and it must be torn.
That doesn’t mean, however, that the entire concept must be abandoned. As for Ms. Anya’s tweet, it wasn’t just discourteous but cruel. Even if one believes the queen and the empire she ostensibly oversaw were responsible for great cruelty, repaying that with further cruelty isn’t justice. It’s the war of all against all, until only one man or woman is left standing. Then, finally, peace and justice will reign on earth.
Courtesy, on the other hand, recognizes the complicated reality of other people. This includes the dead. It teaches that they are valuable, even if they have different ideas and values and even if they are objectively wrong. It doesn’t deny or undermine the importance of truth-telling; it enhances it by recognizing that we don’t speak the full truth when we don’t respect the dignity of others.
As for Queen Elizabeth II, her entire life was based on courtesy, and that will always attract both admiration and scorn. It would be a tragedy, though, if belief in courtesy died with her.
Brandon McGinley is the deputy editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.