When I was young and single, I briefly dated a guy who insisted he had no past. It is possible, he would assert over a bottle of wine in my living room, to become someone who is completely unburdened by what has happened before. According to him, a graduate student in philosophy, we should all only exist in the present.
At the time, I was teaching courses on nonfiction writing at a fairly large university, and I spent a significant amount of time discussing the exact opposite with colleagues and students alike: There was something important about grappling with our messy and imperfect pasts. “We are creatures of context,” I wrote in my journal at the time. “To exist outside of the happenings and people who defined the parameters of existence for us is impossible.”
More specifically, for so many of us, the core wounds that characterize us were inflicted when we were young. To be an adult is to perpetually deal with having once been a child.
“Oh yes,” a therapist friend replied when I brought this up, “90% of it comes down to pre-adulthood trauma. Most of my patients, even people in their 70s and 80s, are still trying to figure out how to talk about (and make sense of) things that happened before they were 18.”
“Good writers understand this (especially post-Freud). We are all haunted by what has happened to us before. It’s really impossible to live only in the present.” Take that, ex-boyfriend.
Unrest in the forest
I went on a retreat last weekend with some friends, all women over 40. I arrived in northern Maryland ready to disconnect, armed with salad fixings, ice cream, beverages, some art supplies, hiking shoes and a copy of Bill Gaythwaite’s Drue Heinz Literature Prize-winning short-story collection, “A Place in the World.” (Gaythwaite will be reading at City of Asylum on Oct. 28th.)
My friends and I were hoping to remove ourselves from the world, finding solace in the simplicity of nature, with no internet or phones in sight — just conversation, crafts and self-kindness. We were to exist in the present. Inevitably, though, we began to discuss our pasts.
We couldn’t help but begin to fill in the forest’s silences with our own stories, as if it were only here, in the quiet of the trees, that we could begin to make sense of ourselves, of all the paths we’d walked to arrive at this, our destination.
At one moment, after a delightful meal, I thought we could all be characters in Gaythweaite’s short story collection, undrowning our sorrows over well-seasoned pasta to explain how we came to be, as if there were a need to justify the long sighs that followed a particularly difficult anecdote.
Trouble with the maples
In “A Place in the World,” Gaythwaite’s characters are doing their best to run from their pasts. But those pesky memories cannot help but emerge. There’s a man who looks back on a good relationship he once squandered, a boy trying to make sense of his own rage due to his father’s abandonment, a girl dreaming for a brother intent on reinventing himself after rehab, and more, all haunted.
We are an amalgamation of all the selves we’ve ever been, Gaythwaite seems to argue, even if we cannot recognize ourselves in the persons we used to be. I told one of my friends at the Maryland retreat about that ex-boyfriend, the one who lived in the present, the man with no past. She thought it ridiculous — how can someone have no past?
A different friend told me to consider our medical histories, the way in which we are all shaped by the genetic memory of our DNA. “We are made entirely of the past. The present is the past made manifest. We are all consequences of every decision we’ve ever encountered.”
This is true in Gaythwaite’s collection. This is true of our current political moment. This is true of our complicated families, now working out plans for next month’s Thanksgiving.
Even when we escape, when we retreat into a forest of our imaginations, the past, even if not our own, will find us.
The oaks can’t help their feelings
Perhaps this is why we resist the past, why people say, “what is past is past,” as if there was a finality to what has already transpired. But the past is being constantly revised, revisited and refashioned. As we grow, as we learn, as we talk things out, we can better make meaning from what we’ve seen.
In “If You Only Knew,” a story in Gaythwaite’s collection, a son explains what his father was up to during a difficult moment in his childhood: “I don’t know all this at the time, but the essentials are pieced together later, as I get older, like the clues in a mystery novel.”
On my drive back from Maryland, I thought about how my friends and I had offered one another those clues — those essential parts of ourselves. We told stories about old boyfriends, present husbands, siblings and bad bosses. In this way, we were all authors, finding the essentials, the things that make a collection feel whole, alive and fully engaged with the present.
Adriana E. Ramírez’s previous column was “Democrats should not be afraid to primary John Fetterman.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.