“You should never call the police on a group of protesters,” an activist I know posted on their social media. “Unless, of course, you’re protesting my house. Then I’m calling the cops immediately.”
They were joking, of course, but their joke revealed the inherent tension between citizenry and the police: We are good with law enforcement until they threaten us, we are apprehensive of law enforcement until we need them.
It’s how a perfectly law-abiding citizen can both agree and disagree with the decision by the Pittsburgh City Council sergeant at arms to ask for backup during a July 2 City Council meeting devoted to discussing Stop Violence Grants.
Order, order, order
City Council Chambers were full beyond capacity. Some folks among the over 100 people who signed up to comment stood behind Council Members and blocked the door.
People couldn’t move away, even after being asked, as there was nowhere else to stand. That made it difficult for the one officer there — there are usually two — to ensure the safety of everyone in the room.
Four city officers responded to the request for additional support, as well as two deputies from the Allegheny County Sheriff’s Office, who soon left. The police officers did nothing but exist in the space. They did not arrest anyone, and as far as has been widely reported, none of them even really spoke.
Was the sergeant at arms wrong to ask for additional officers? Depends on who you ask.
People are not unreasonable for worrying, though, no matter how unthreatening the officers may behave. To the people assembled peacefully in Council Chambers, the sudden police presence felt like intimidation. The event was non-violent — passionate, sure. But no one posed a credible risk to anyone’s safety.
“Calling law enforcement on residents peacefully lobbying for anti-violence initiatives is, at best, puzzling and, at worst, deeply troubling,” Councilmen R. Daniel Lavelle and Khari Mosley wrote in a statement posted July 5 to social media, calling for an investigation into the matter.
“I found it incredibly unnecessary and troubling that the sergeant at arms felt that was necessary,” Mosley said.
“It could potentially send a signal out that the people aren’t welcome in their own house,” he continued, as reported by KDKA. “When people come to lobby and advocate the folks they elected into office, that when they come there, they could potentially be seen as a threat.”
A badge and a gun
An old friend of mine is a police officer. Over the years, I’ve chatted with him a lot about his job and how he feels in the role. He loves being a cop, but he also understands why police presence can increase the chance of violence.
When I explained the situation in Pittsburgh over the phone this week, he told me everyone was right. “The sergeant at arms was right to call for backup — the situation warranted it. The people were right to be angry. More cops arriving increases the chance that bad [things] will happen.”
“It absolutely signals to people that they are not wanted. Do not doubt it,” he said, before pausing. “That being said, as a police officer in that moment? Always call for backup.”
“It’s just a bad situation, for everyone,” I said.
“You’d be surprised how often that’s the case with the public and the police,” he replied.
As time has passed, initial reactions have gone from a raging boil to a lively simmer. After speaking to the sergeant at arms, most council members are now in agreement that he acted correctly — even Lavelle and Mosley.
“It was a breakdown in communication more than anything else,” Mosley said, heaping praises on the long-serving sergeant and asking for no penalties. Mosley still stands by the need for review, though, as better policies could prevent further misunderstandings.
“In that moment, the optics looked really bad, and that’s what people were reacting to — and understandably so,” Lavelle said, also agreeing on no penalties for the sergeant at arms.
They have the authority
The officer did his job. But members of the community still felt unsafe and uncomfortable, “gaslit when we’re coming here and speaking our opinions on behalf of ourselves, our babies and our communities,” as one speaker said in council chambers on Tuesday. Both things can be true.
And while it might be tempting for some to make this about race, and I’m not saying that that is not a factor, I believe that to some degree, this is true across all communities.
I’ve seen the most Thin-Blue-Line dudes rage against the police when they believe they’ve been stopped or arrested without reason. I’ve seen the most Defund-the-Police people call the cops over a minor issue.
We are all walking contradictions, and this is certainly true of how we feel about law enforcement on any given day. And as my cop friend points out, that’s also true of the police:
“We’re humans too. We get scared. We make bad assumptions about people, just like people make bad assumptions about us.”
Adriana E. Ramírez’s previous column was “Texas needs flood sirens, but doesn’t want them.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.