In 1982, the superintendent of Pittsburgh Public Schools warned “that proposed cutbacks in federal aid are threatening programs and leading toward future tax increases.”
Richard C. Wallace Jr. noted back then that “we are very much aware and concerned about the devastating effects of proposals by Reagan.” A city councilman warned that any cuts to the budget would “severely affect the local tax situation.”
Forty years later, the local tax situation is severely affected — and not just by Reagan. And it will remain so until the city, the school district and state government get it together to unravel decades of tit-for-tat tax local earned income tax legislation that has added needless layers of complexity to their relationship, and to Pittsburgh’s municipal revenue streams.
It also reveals what happens when the two most important entities in the city, its government and its schools, don’t get along. But there’s little incentive for them to do so. This fight existed in 1961. It existed in 1989. It exists in 2024, and it will come up again and again, until something, anything is done.
I work all night
PPS has always had several sources of revenue, including funds from the state, grants and local sources — namely property taxes and, more controversially, since 1961 an earned income tax.
The Post-Gazette Editorial Board noted back then that a tax of 0.5% on earned income would lead to improvements in the school district, which would then “persuade more young parents to rear their children in this city.”
In the late 1950s, there were twice the number of people living in Pittsburgh, so a .5% wage tax was enough to help fund the district. But managing a city in decline is a different and more difficult matter. As the number of people who earn money and own property here has dwindled, the city and schools have both increased earned income taxes.
PPS and the city are intrinsically linked. The health of the city reflects the health of its school district and vice versa. These two major government entities can greatly increase or decrease the appeal of moving here. They can and should work together — and that’s not what’s happening, which only makes things worse for everyone.
I work all day
Recruiting parents to Pittsburgh was on the mind of Mayor Sophie Masloff when she decided to increase property taxes while equally reducing the city’s earned income tax rate in late 1989. The idea was to keep a balanced budget, while encouraging more young people to move to Pittsburgh, helping the city and the school district in the long run. Or so the Masloff administration thought.
Pittsburgh Public Schools responded to the city’s decrease in earned income taxes by raising their own tax rate, because as one long-time insider told me, “taxpayers were already used to paying it” and the district needed the money. Ms. Masloff and City Council were livid.
So in 1990, city residents paid 1% of their income to Pittsburgh and another 2% to PPS. This held until 2004, when the city entered financial management by the state, which forced the school district to effectively “return” a quarter-percent of the earned income taxes to the city as a part of Pittsburgh’s financial recovery plan. The state compensated the school district for its losses, but over time, state funds have not kept pace with rising costs.
So for the last 20 years, the schools have given an eighth of their collected earned income taxes to the city of Pittsburgh, with no end date in sight. This means that in 2025 PPS will hand over $25 million of its revenue to the city. At the same time, PPS is projecting budgetary losses in the range of $20 million next year.
Ain’t it sad?
Today, the city administers a 3% earned income tax and funnels 1.75% to PPS. If the city were flush, it would be easy for it to pass along the full 2%, and let this decades-long feud fade into the past.
But the truth is that the city is not flush. Meanwhile it, the schools and the state have a complicated financial dance going on that makes less and less sense the more an intrepid researcher tries to comprehend it.
I’m not sure any of it is fair — to the schools, the city and the taxpayer alike.
Laws keep getting passed on top of other laws, and digging all the way down to the original intent — or the original sin — proves impossible. After all, even the 1961 decision for the school to levy earned income taxes was controversial. The city had only been doing so for 7 years at that point. People saw no reason why schools, or city government, should be taking people’s hard earned income in the first place.
“That’s what property taxes are for,” a man told the Pittsburgh Press in 1961.
It’s time for everyone to go back to the drawing board. We need local taxes that make sense. People want to support their city, and they want to support their local schools. But in order for both institutions to better serve the city of Pittsburgh, they need to put their financial differences aside.
Before their squabbles, and higher taxes for all, push even more people away.
Adriana E. Ramírez’s previous column was “Do CEO lives matter? Does anyone’s?”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.