Many of my friends are “childless cat ladies.” Some are single and still waiting for the right person to start their family with. Some no longer have children. Some never had the biological opportunity to have children. Some never wanted kids at all. Some are stepmothers, who bristle at the notion that they are “childless.”
According to Statista, 46.8% of women in the U.S. are childless. The U.S. Census Bureau estimates that there are 22 million women between 20 and 40 in the United States who, for whatever reason, are not considered mothers.
Me? Before my husband and I chose to have kids, I was a childless dog lady and quite happy to remain so if that was what fate had in store for me.
By now, many readers have heard vice-presidential candidate and Ohio Senator JD Vance’s comments on the matter, via a resurfaced interview from three years ago, where he noted that our country was being run by “a bunch of childless cat ladies who are miserable at their own lives and the choices that they’ve made and so they want to make the rest of the country miserable too.”
Yikes.
Helping families?
In Vance’s estimation, a person without children “has no stake in the country’s future,” despite countless childless women serving as mentors, teachers and aunties to the children in their lives. When confronted with his comments on a friendly infotainment outlet, Vance found himself without a knife as he talked himself into a gordian knot of contradictions.
Or as he told Megyn Kelly, in an ill-timed attempt at humor, “obviously, it was a sarcastic comment. I’ve got nothing against cats.”
“This is not about criticizing people who for various reasons don’t have kids,” he continued. “This is about criticizing the Democratic Party for becoming anti-family and anti-child.”
He says this as his colleagues in the Senate continue to oppose an expansion of the child tax credit before Congress (a vote he skipped). Even Republican Senator Josh Hawley of Missouri sees the blatant anti-family hypocrisy at play.
“As Republicans, we should be in favor of helping people who want to have families,” Hawley told NBC.
Childless and happy
Childless women are, on the whole, happier than women who are parents. According to a study released by the Institute for Family Studies, women who have never had children are happier than their retired peers who had children that no longer live at home. And both those groups are happier than 50 to 70 year old women with fewer than three children still living at home.
So when Vance calls childless women “miserable at their own lives,” what does he mean? Childless women usually have more income, more freedom to travel and more time to fulfill their personal goals and ambitions. And yes, for some of us, motherhood is that ambition fulfilled and we find ourselves quite joyous in our roles.
But that’s the beauty of living in the United States: women (for now) get to choose what they want without judgment. Well, without judgment from the folks I know. The childless women in my life who are sad — or as Vance put it, “miserable” — are the ones who were not able to have children, to their immense heartache. And for Vance to mock them seems unusually cruel and mean-spirited.
If Vance wants to make motherhood more appealing for women who can have children in this country, there are some policy and cultural shifts that could help.
Want fewer childless cat ladies? Cool. Offer universal pre-K, robust government-paid medical services, generous maternity and paternity leaves and expand that child tax credit without imposing onerous conditions. Support IVF for those who need it and family planning for those who want it too.
Create a culture where men value women and don’t constantly demean them. Promote healthy role models instead of toxic masculinity. As my younger heterosexually-inclined girlfriends report, dating these days is a game in which a good woman has to cut through a forest of entitled and resentful men to find a decent one.
Make marriage more appealing to women by keeping “no fault” divorce statutes. Offer better protections for victims of domestic violence. Make child-having more appealing instead of just launching insults at people who choose otherwise.
Bad politics
In addition to revealing his inner bully, JD Vance’s comments also reveal that he is really bad at politics. Women, including childless ones, have been a decisive factor in the last few elections, and in attacking them and then doubling-down on his comments, he risks losing far more than he could ever gain. Being the darling of women-haters (many of them childless) can only get you so many new votes.
And if the portents are true, Vance might be in trouble. A few days ago Taylor Swift, the most powerful childless woman in the world, with an army of voting-aged devotees, changed the bio on one of her social media accounts to “this is pretty much just a cat account.”
JD Vance should be worried about the choices he’s making — and not trying to make the rest of us more miserable for them.
Adriana E. Ramírez, author of “Dead Boys,” is a columnist and InReview editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. Her previous column was “The artful decadence of the French Olympics.” Find her on X: @zadri.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.