In a CBS News Poll released last week, 53% of Hispanic respondents favored the government “starting a new national program to deport all undocumented immigrants currently living in the U.S. illegally.”

Many people outside the Latino community were surprised. Latinos are supposed to universally favor immigration from Latin America. We are supposed to have the same views on American laws, border policy, citizenship, nationality. But we don’t.

Anyone who believes that Latinos are a monolith knows very little about the Latino community. We are a complex bunch, hailing from somewhere between 20 and 44 countries, depending on the definition of “latinoamerica” you use. We span all races, we cross all economic thresholds and those of us who speak Spanish do so with very different accents.

And we all have our own immigration stories.

Advertise with us

My father, a very conservative Latino who immigrated to the United States legally in the early 1980s, is a staunch opponent of undocumented immigration. He firmly believes that because he “did things correctly” that others should too. His viewpoint is not new.

Us vs. Them

It’s a question of who we are and therefore who they are.

When Irish immigrants arrived in the Americas, they faced great prejudice from established communities, often facing accusations of criminality and suspicion. But within a few years, Irish-Americans perpetuated the same accusations on Italian immigrants, often decrying them as “members of a criminal race,” as Jennifer Guglielmo writes in “Are Italians White?: How Race is Made in America.”

In the “us versus them” construction of American identity, there is no space for the ethnic to co-exist with the national. It’s why many Americans bristle at the idea of a hyphenated-American existence and it’s why over one hundred years after Irish-American and Italian-American tension, Donald Trump can ask Steve Cortes, his former advisor, at a rally who he would choose: “the country or the Hispanics?”

As Michelle García notes in the magazine Palabra, Latinos living in the United States have always been subject to loyalty checks. Attempts were always made to make Latinos think of themselves as part of “us” and other Latinos as “them.”

Advertise with us

She highlights a moment from Texas history, when “Governor James E. Ferguson issued a Loyalty Proclamation in 1916 commanding absolute loyalty from ethnic Mexicans living in the state.” Mexicans were to report any bandits badmouthing Americans or American treatment of Mexicans. “Show you are loyal to this country.”

García writes: “Ethnic Mexicans who failed to demonstrate sufficient ‘loyalty,’ warned Ferguson, ‘will bring trouble upon themselves and many crimes will be committed which cannot be prevented.’”

Organizations like the League of United Latin American Citizens, “which urged members toward aggressive displays of patriotism and military service,” as García notes, are born from the same compromise. To be American is to renounce Latinidad, to divorce yourself from a monolith that never was.

And at the center of this is the idea that the upstanding and assimilated immigrant does not support, and will never support, the bandit — the person who sneaks across, who breaks the law. For people like my father, who became a U.S. citizen after navigating a complicated immigration system and family history with great patience and faith in the process, anyone who immigrates differently undermines his own experience.

No one likes people who cut in line (unless they are very skilled or rich). It feels anti-American.

Advertise with us

Still — it’s highly likely that the grandchildren of people who immigrated illegally also support mass deportations. The further we are from our family’s immigration stories, the more likely we are to view illegal immigration distastefully.

Or as one of my more conservative friends put it, “when my family arrived, there weren’t even really laws about immigration. What does that have to do with immigration today?”

Rite of passage

I support legal immigration, and I believe that anyone working here without authorization should still be treated with dignity and respect. My father believes the same thing. We just disagree on what “dignity and respect” actually means and whether or not “rule breakers deserve the same experience.”

Like many Latinos who are also American citizens, my father thinks our country has a scarcity of resources and opportunities, and that sneaky “us versus them” mentality emerges. It’s why so many undocumented Mexicans in the U.S. resent undocumented Africans and Central Americans — “they’re coming for what’s ours” the argument goes.

As the CBS poll shows, more and more, Latinos see themselves as removed from the question of undocumented immigration, even if non-Latino Americans tend to conflate being Hispanic and being an immigrant.

Advertise with us

It is an American rite of passage for newly arrived immigrants, legal or not, to face the worst of everyday Americans. But Latinos, who have been in America since before its inception, cannot seem to shake the “newly arrived” label.

In Pittsburgh, it’s easy for any cluster of Spanish speakers to face taunts of “go back home,” even if their families have lived here for decades. I’ve certainly had racist encounters in this city. And yes, most of these racist encounters have occurred since the emergence of MAGA.

“It is becoming acceptable to dehumanize immigrants on a regular basis,” Vanessa Cárdenas, the executive director of immigrant rights group America’s Voice, told the Washington Post. “There’s no real pushback.”

Not even from their own people — nor could there be. Latinos were never a monolith. It’s time America learns that too.

Adriana E. Ramírez, author of “Dead Boys,” is a columnist and InReview editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. Her previous column was “The reason your orange juice is getting more expensive.” Find her on X: @zadri.