The Carnegie Museum of Art’s leaders have regrets. They regret holding on to a piece of art that was stolen during the Holocaust from a Jewish art collector. They regret not thoroughly investigating the work’s provenance. They regret accepting the drawing as a valuable gift, only to then have it seized by the Manhattan District Attorney’s office without compensation.
The Carnegie Museum is obviously not alone — hundreds of museums have acquired art with dubious histories The Art Institute of Chicago and Allen Memorial Art Museum at Oberlin College in Ohio also had art works by the same artist seized.
The art world is shady, and always has been. Objects that are both fragile and priceless pass through dozens of hands, each one becoming a part of its recorded history. An artwork can be purchased legally, despite having been stolen decades prior, as long as the provenance seems legitimate. That’s how a museum can own a piece of art that isn’t discovered as stolen until decades later.
The museum allowed the proper authorities to seize the drawing, “Portrait of a Man,” by Egon Schiele. It has also pledged to “cooperate fully with inquiries from the relevant authorities,” and to preserve “the resources of art and science by acting in accordance with ethical, legal, and professional requirements and norms.”
A season of atonement
The museum’s regrets come at a fitting time of year: Monday is Yom Kippur, the holiest of Jewish holidays. It is the day G-d has set aside for deep reflection. To quote Leviticus, “for on this day atonement shall be made for you to purify you of all your sins.”
For the family whose art was stolen, the Grünbaums, whom the New York Times points out are “descended of a prominent Jewish art collector and cabaret artist killed at the Dachau concentration camp in Germany in 1941,” atonement comes in the form of receiving the artwork itself.
The physical object carries with it a history that includes the memory of their ancestor. In returning the painting to the Grünbaums, the Manhattan DA is attempting to correct, in the small way available to him, the Nazi pillaging of decades ago.
Reparations are due to families like the Grünbaums, families that suffered as others prospered from their pain. But should the Carnegie Museum of Art bear the brunt of those amends?
Undoing the consequences
Every year, as Yom Kippur rolls around, I begin the job of reflecting on the last year. What have I done? How have I transgressed? Whom have I hurt?
I think a lot about pride — about how difficult it is to perform a truly accurate accounting of the self. Have I been disloyal? Have I been slanderous? Have I held on to something when I really needed to be letting go? Have I always acted with good faith?
Atonement is complicated. The self-awareness required can feel impossible. And to truly “atone,” one has to not only speak to their sin, but also be ready to make palpable amends — to undo that which has been done.
Amends, as anyone going through a 12-step program knows, require a lot of uncomfortable self-examination, and vulnerability. How can one express a very real desire for forgiveness? And what does it look like to demonstrate repentance?
The last thing we want is for our children to feel obligated to make amends on our behalf. I would rather deal with my own discomfort than risk my sins falling through the cracks of history, for someone else to deal with.
To put it in art terms, I’d prefer to give the drawing back now, instead of making my grandchildren return that which was never theirs in the first place.
Looking for reparations
For hundreds of years, Western Europe used empire and colonialism to take natural resources and labor from less developed lands and peoples. The rise in immigration from these places is a balancing act — how could a country like Belgium exploit Central African resources for centuries without having to contend with her people, in turn, seeking a better life?
But that’s a hard sell for the current people of Belgium, who are the descendants of the original sinners, as much as the current wave of immigrants are descended from those originally sinned-against.
This parallels the issue of reparations for Black Americans. Despite slavery officially ending in the 19th century, the ramifications of hundreds of years of free labor from a subjugated population can be felt today. But reparations are not freely given — many people feel that the descendants of enslaved people do not deserve special consideration, that amends ended generations ago.
When does the transgression end?
But can we so easily escape the past? The Carnegie Museum received “Portrait of a Man” as a gift from an Austrian-American art historian and gallerist. The museum did not buy the artwork from Nazi soldiers; its purchase was perfectly legal. Is it their fault that Egon Schiele’s “Portrait of a Man” ended up in their archive? No.
But do they still have to make things right? Yes.
As a Jewish person, I strongly believe in Tikkun olam, the idea of repairing and improving the world through action. We bring honor to G-d by bettering the lives of people around us. To repair the world is to let it be a just world, and justice takes as long as it has to.
That means returning “Portrait of a Man” to the Grünbaums, even if an apparently innocent museum has to bear the cost. It means opening our hearts to one another, acknowledging how we have benefited from the sins of our ancestors. And it means considering all the ways we can atone for our sins — past, present and future.
So our kids don’t have to pay the price.
Adriana E. Ramírez, author of “Dead Boys,” is a columnist and InReview editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: aramirez@post-gazette.com.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.