As I write this, jurors have finished deliberating whether the Pittsburgh synagogue shooter is eligible for the death penalty. Now the debate begins about whether he should be sentenced to death.
For two weeks, jurors have listened to the gunman’s defense, led by Judy Clarke, a noble anti-death penalty crusader. As I have written before, her task was impossible. There is turmoil in my community about the justice of the death penalty, and I’m still on the fence most days. But I count myself lucky, every day, that his fate does not rest in my hands.

I don’t know if I could live with myself — regardless of the choice.
As I’ve watched and read summaries of Ms. Clarke’s defense of the shooter, I keep turning to the same questions: How does one save the life of a person so willing to take it? What story can anyone tell that lessens the wreckage one man’s hatred can cause? Who, if anyone, deserves to die at the hands of the state?
There are no easy answers. As an intellectual exercise, I contemplate what I would say in his defense, and the only true answer I can give is: “because we’re better than this.” But I also see the satisfaction and justice in his demise.
At the heart of it all was whether or not the gunman “had the capacity to truly form the intent to kill,” as Megan Guza and Hallie Lauer wrote for the Post-Gazette.
Proving intent is not easy, but in this case, there are four possibilities that can be proved by the prosecution: he intentionally killed the victims; he intentionally inflicted serious bodily injury; he intentionally participated in an act that resulted in death; he participated in an act of violence knowing that act created a grave risk of death. Just proving one was enough to establish eligibility.
The defense argued that the gunman did not have the capacity, that he was unable to fully understand exactly what he had resolved to do. They argued that he was schizophrenic, or at the very least had neurological issues that led to “psychotic delusions.” The defense, led by Ms. Clarke, argued that his “impairments” mitigated the capacity to form the intent his actions demonstrated.
The question seemed to be: Is it noble to put a sick man to death?
In the trial, there’s been a lot of talk about epilepsy and brain lesions and the effects these could have on an already delusional person. “I don’t think there was an ability to make a choice,” Dr. Nadkarni, a defense witness, said during cross-examination. “He could carry out a plan, of course, but I don’t think he could inhibit a plan he wants to carry out.”
But the truth is that the gunman did make a choice, as demonstrated by his extensive planning. So many people with mental health issues do not shoot up innocent people attending religious services. Millions of people live with abnormal brains, or with schizo-affective disorders, and very, very few of them feel the need to hurt others as a consequence of their impairments.
The gunman was motivated by hatred, the prosecution countered, not by diagnosable delusions. Just because his beliefs were grounded in conspiracy theories and hatred, they pointed out, does not mean that they were irrational or the product of brain lesions: “Widely held beliefs, even if they are held with the utmost conviction, are not delusions.” The gunman really believed he was a soldier in a war against his kind.
“He did not just believe [his conduct] to be correct,” forensic psychologist Richard Rogers said, “he believed it absolutely had to be done.” Mr. Rogers went on to call the gunman “grossly psychotic,” as if that lessened the impact of his actions.
In truth, it seemed like the defense was working less towards solving the question of eligibility, than it was in arguing that the man was not responsible for his choices.
But if this man is not responsible for his choices and his actions, then no one is. His childhood might have been unpleasant and brain topography might have been unusual, but nothing fully absolved him. Ms. Clarke’s attempts were audacious, but nothing she argued or revealed could remove responsibility from the murderer. It took jurors less than a day to agree.
That, however, was the easy part. Now jurors must decide whether the gunman should be condemned to death.
Watching Ms. Clarke's attempt to save his life has been a lesson in humility for me, and I’m still not sure how I would proceed were I on the jury. To take someone’s life is no easy task. They have already listened to several grueling weeks of testimony, determined his guilt and today declared him eligible to die at the hands of the state. Now, they have to decide whether to levy the greatest punishment we have.
This has taken careful deliberation, along with hours and hours of expert testimony. Nothing about this process has been rash or easy. Killing a person is unfathomable to most of us. Deciding what to do with a killer forces us to confront that inhumanity, and decide the most humane way to respond.
The Jewish community in Pittsburgh has been torn apart by this man: first by his actions, and then by how to determine his fate. So many of us are simply waiting for this to be over, for his future to be decided one way or the other, for a modicum of justice to be achieved.
The gunman’s delusions killed eleven people and wrecked their families. His thoughts and beliefs, no matter what led to them, were not idle. And in finding him eligible for the death penalty, the jury has affirmed that he must be held responsible for his actions. The final question is how.
Adriana E. Ramírez, author of “Dead Boys,” is a columnist and InReview editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: aramirez@post-gazette.com.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.