On the morning of October 27, 2018, my family decided to go to the pumpkin patch. The night before, we had agreed not to attend services at our temple that evening or the next morning. Instead, we loaded up our six-month-old baby into the car and drove out to the suburbs, wanting to avoid crowds and be among the first at the farm when it opened.
As we pulled into the parking lot of a place that promised hayrides and the biggest gourds in western Pennsylvania, messages began to appear on my phone. My husband told me to ignore them, to enjoy the drizzly and slightly chilly day with our kid. But soon his phone started pinging too.
After scrolling through several questions of concern from loved ones and family members, we turned on the car radio. I still think of this moment — my husband, my baby and I, sitting in our hatchback, listening to reports of an active shooter at a synagogue. And not just any synagogue — one we drive by every day, and a sister congregation to our own.
We sat quietly, reading the news, as the baby fussed in the back seat. The shooter attacked because one of the congregations housed in the synagogue had supported HIAS, the Hebrew Immigrant Aid Society, at a refugee shabbat.

A forty-six year old man was killing people because they’d helped immigrants. Because our faith is one that recognizes the pain of displacement. Because we are a people of compassion and empathy.
As the news continued, I sobbed in the front seat of our little car. My husband held my hand and began to pray. The baby, confused at why his parents were crying, joined us in a small but collective wail.
Read More
A not uncommon event
There is a numbness that comes with shootings in our country. To some degree, we have grown accustomed to such things. After all, on any given day in the United States of America, there is a mass shooting.
There were 340 mass shootings in 2018, according to the Gun Violence Archive, a nonprofit that tracks shootings in the U.S. That’s almost as many shootings as days in a year.
But this time, it was in Pittsburgh. But this time, it was someone attacking people of my faith. But this time, it was a gunman shooting people for helping people who look like me.
We eventually got out of the car. I decided that we’d driven out to the pumpkin patch, dammit, and no matter how much my heart hurt in this moment, it was crucial to live.
I cannot look at photographs from that morning without seeing my husband’s sadness and my own. We went through the motions of putting the baby in front of pumpkins, bouncing him up and down as a wagon pulled us around — but the whole time, my heart was in Squirrel Hill.
How could we be living just as other people were dying?
An impossible decision
My son is five years old now. The trial of the Pittsburgh synagogue shooter begins next week, and I’m doing my best not to think about all the feelings swirling in my body. It is a death penalty trial, and there is no doubt of the shooter’s guilt. It’s simply a matter of determining his fate.
I cannot name him, this man. I will not type his name, because to me, he has no name. He is a finger on a trigger, a gun, the human embodiment of hatred, a person who has sacrificed his name due to his actions.
To name him is to dishonor the good people who share his name. To name him is to enshrine him in memory. To name him is to give him infamy that could inspire others.
No, to me, he has no name. He is a shooter; he is an anti-semite; he is anti-immigrant; he is anti-Latino; he is everything I imagine in my nightmares.
To name him would make him more human.

I’m simply not ready to grant him humanity, which is a problem on its own. And I don’t know how to reconcile it all. I am staunchly against the death penalty.
Except not in this case.
I’m grateful that I will not be on this jury. Because as a Jewish Latina and immigrant, I cannot decide what outcome I’d prefer. I can only breathe, grateful that I can.
A community torn apart
As my friends and neighbors prepare for the trial, we are divided.
Some want to see the shooter dead. Some want to see him locked away for life. The rest of us oscillate between the two.
I decided one morning last month that I could not let the shooter take my own humanity, that I should fight for his life as I would anyone else’s. That there was a value to preserving life, even of the most hateful person. That I was not G-d to decide someone’s fate.
And then I read the statement from the victims and their families describing why they favor the death penalty.
I simply do not know. Still.
I do not envy this jury. I do not envy our community.
My husband is livid. “I wish the trial wasn’t here,” he said this morning, watching me revisit the pumpkin-patch photographs. “Maybe if it were in Tallahassee, or the moon, it would be a little easier to process all this.”
I disagree with him but don’t say so out loud. It should be here — there is no fairness to be had anywhere in a trial like this. And it’s easier for more people to attend and to testify if it’s near.
My neighbor, J., tells me that she hopes the shooter fries in hell: “Even though I don’t believe in hell, I will make an exception for this man.” A friend who used to attend services at Tree of Life tells me he simply wants “everyone to find justice, whatever that means.”
My friend L. tells me that she worries about her children, “it’s hard to explain that the biggest attack against our people in the United States happened three blocks away from our house.” How will they feel safe?
A poet writes to me, “I know how heavy this all is. But we must find happiness. We must think of everything our people have been through. Survival is what matters. It’s why we praise G-d. Because we lived.”
But we didn’t all live.
I don’t say that out loud either.
An open ear
All we can do right now is listen.
After jury selection is through, it will be a matter of law and argument. The defense has a daunting task ahead of it, to humanize a shooter. As does the prosecution — to call for the death of a human being.
As we discuss the upcoming trial at the dinner table, my son and my daughter (who is three) do not understand the hushed tones and euphemisms my husband and I use.
Eventually, as a Jewish family, we will have to have our version of The Talk, something I will have to do again as a brown-skinned mother.

There are people in this world who hate us, simply for being. It’s not a lesson I want to teach, but it’s one I must.
We must tell the story of what happened. And as survivors and their families take the stage in the upcoming trial, it’s crucial we listen. It’s the only way this won’t happen again. All of us, of all faiths and persuasions, must listen.
This happened here. And there are people still here who have to live with this immense loss, with the void left by devastation.
Adriana E. Ramírez is a columnist and InReview editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: aramirez@post-gazette.com.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.