A few weeks ago, Rep. Conor Lamb, D-Mt. Lebanon, sent a letter calling for a federal investigation into the catastrophe at Brighton Rehabilitation and Wellness Center in Beaver County. Brighton has been devastated by COVID-19, on a scale even greater than many other nursing homes and senior living facilities in the state. But a federal investigation of Brighton is misguided, and if the goal is to get to the bottom of the tragedy, it misses the mark entirely.
With two-thirds of Pennsylvania's COVID-19 deaths occurring in nursing homes, it is becoming clear that Gov. Tom Wolf's administration was not just unprepared to protect the most vulnerable of Pennsylvania's citizens, it had made a strategic miscalculation. Mr. Lamb, who has remained largely silent in recent months, should be looking to Mr. Wolf and Secretary of Health Dr. Rachel Levine for answers, not Washington.
We knew long before COVID-19 hit American soil that older adults were disproportionately dying from coronavirus and that communal-living facilities were at greatest risk. As early as February, Pennsylvanians saw what was inevitably headed our way. We were tuning in to watch evening newscasts filled with images of the virus ravaging Italy's elderly population and witnessed one of the first U.S. coronavirus outbreaks at a Washington state nursing home. At the same time, the World Health Organization was warning governments in North and South America of outbreaks in "care homes."
Dr. Levine heard the warning loud and clear and even removed her own mother from a personal care home in order to protect her from the virus. Mr. Wolf frequently assures us, "Pennsylvania will make informed decisions based on data and science," but his administration still neglected to provide appropriate oversight, PPE, testing and funding to help protect those whom science has already indicated were the most vulnerable in the state. It seems that nursing home patients were all but forgotten by our leaders in Harrisburg.
Cue Mr. Lamb, who rode in earlier this month, not like a knight on his white horse, but more like a kid running after the school bus he missed. By the time 78 of his constituents had died, he must have figured he should do something. Demonstrating the Democratic party's propensity for investigations, Mr. Lamb demanded an examination of the "competence and performance" of Brighton's management and the facility's temporary manager in a letter writing frenzy to the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services and the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services.
However, Mr. Lamb's actions were too little, too late for more than 3,000 Pennsylvania seniors who have died in long-term care facilities around the commonwealth, including those at Brighton. The congressman's recent grandstanding did little more than create political fervor and anxiety to cover up his own lack of leadership and foresight.
It was no secret to the federal government that Brighton struggled, even before coronavirus, to maintain a safe living environment for its residents. The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services gave it a “much below average," one-star overall rating on a five-star scale. The facility receives three times the average number of health citations of nursing homes in Pennsylvania, has been flagged for potential abuse and has a history of failing to provide and implement infection-prevention and control programs.
Brighton was identified as needing special assistance to improve the quality of its care and has spent the past 27 months on a federal special-focus facilities list of the nation's nursing homes with a "history of serious quality issues.” According to the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, these special focus facilities have "more problems ... more serious problems ... and a pattern of serious problems that has persisted over a long period of time."
Only 2.5%, of the nation's nursing homes qualify to join this list of the country's worst long-term care facilities, and despite their bad track records, they are not subject to any additional oversight or inspections as they wait in line for federal funding to address their needs.
Special-focus facilities, like Brighton, were ticking time bombs during the pandemic. The recent release by the Pennsylvania Department of Health of nursing home level data on COVID-19 infections and deaths illuminates the problem in vivid life-and-death terms. So far, more than 200 of the 3,234 COVID-19 deaths in Pennsylvania nursing homes can be attributed to just nine facilities on the special-focus facility list, and Brighton with its 76 deaths is at the top of it.
Mr. Lamb represents one of the oldest congressional districts in the nation. Twenty-seven percent of the population is age 60 and over. Pennsylvania's plan to protect residents of long-term living communities should have been his top priority, too. He should not have waited until May to finally take action. Mr. Lamb's calls in May for more oversight and assistance for Brighton seem all the more disingenuous now that he remains silent on the Pennsylvania National Guard's withdrawal from the facility last Tuesday after only eight days at the site.
Mr. Lamb should have filled an urgent need for leadership in Western Pennsylvania's fight against coronavirus. He should have been on the front end of protecting his constituents and calling on the state's Department of Health and the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services to step up their inspections of facilities, especially those on the federal special-focus facilities list, in March and April, not in May after 76 people died at Brighton.
Seniors in Mr. Lamb's district were depending on him to be their voice and to demand that Pennsylvania's action plan to fight coronavirus address failing nursing homes first and, as the science suggests, make protecting seniors and long-term care facilities the cornerstone of the state's defense against COVID-19, not an afterthought.
Mr. Lamb also missed an opportunity to use the power of the bully pulpit to shed light on the Wolf administration's ludicrous policy of forcing nursing homes to accept COVID-19 positive patients into their communal-living environments. Nursing homes and other long-term care facilities are intended to be communal-living spaces where residents and staff are mobile and fluid in their day-to-day lives. Sending sick patients back into an environment that was not designed to isolate residents is, and has been, a recipe for disaster during a pandemic.
Our congressional representatives should be our loudest advocates because they can often bridge the gap between local, state and national resources. Even though Mr. Lamb had the resources to pinpoint the weak links in western Pennsylvania's COVID-19 defense and call for state and federal officials to shore up struggling facilities in advance of any outbreaks, Mr. Lamb's modus operandi has been to stand idly by on the most controversial of subjects, especially if it means confronting leaders in his own party.
Western Pennsylvania's pandemic response requires bold leadership. Mr. Lamb missed his opportunity, and unfortunately, his constituents are paying the price.
Mary Ann Meloy was deputy director of the White House Office of Public Liaison during the administration of Ronald Reagan, and a former deputy secretary for the Pennsylvania Department of Aging during the Thornburgh administration.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.