State Senate President Pro Tempore Joe Scarnati is leaving office at the end of the year, but not without first attempting to exact some payback against journalists who had the audacity to delve into his campaign spending.

Mr. Scarnati’s campaign committee filed suit in August against The Caucus, a publication of Lancaster-based LNP Media Group; Caucus reporter Brad Bumstead; and Spotlight PA reporter Angela Couloumbis. The campaign is seeking more than $5,000 for the cost of producing campaign records — public records, we might add — and another $1,000 in legal fees.

The lawsuit amounts to little more than a vile combination of retribution and intimidation on the part of Mr. Scarnati and his campaign committee, who were likely displeased with the rather unflattering items the journalists turned up in the course of their reporting.

In reviewing nearly $3.5 million in campaign spending by Mr. Scarnati, R-Jefferson, and other lawmakers between 2016 and 2018, the journalists found that many expenses lacked any detailed explanation for the actual spending.

Advertise with us

In the case of Mr. Scarnati, the amount of unspecified spending totaled nearly $246,000. Included in the spending were vague descriptions such as “lodging” listed by the campaign without noting it was for a hotel room in Germany during a 2016 European trip. Other expenses were merely listed as credit card payments without any further details.

The Scarnati campaign stored the records with an accounting firm and attempted to bill the journalists about $2,000 to produce the public records. Fortunately, the Pennsylvania Department of State put a stop to that effort by sending a letter to Mr. Scarnati’s lawyer pointing out that state law allows only fees for copying — 25 cents per page — and delivery.

Undaunted, the Scarnati campaign is now asking the common pleas court of Jefferson County to order the payment by the journalists.

Although there’s no telling how the courts in Mr. Scarnati’s home district might rule, this lawsuit amounts to little more than an attempt to intimidate the journalists named in the action, as well as any others who would attempt to hold lawmakers accountable in the future. If Mr. Scarnati and his campaign succeed, other legislators could follow a similar path — use an accounting firm to maintain campaign spending records, and then charge exorbitant fees to produce these public records.

That would have a chilling effect on not only journalists but also the public at large, which has the same right to such records.

The courts should not allow such a blatant attempt at stifling investigative journalism and political transparency.