Senate Democrats and liberal commentators are getting themselves in a lather over the president nominating and the Republicans attempting to confirm a new Supreme Court justice before the presidential election.

One senator said the nomination and vote would be a “desecration” of the Senate.

This is not only hyperbolic nonsense, it is muddy thinking.

Constitutionally, the president has the right to make nominations to the court. That is in Article II, Section 2, of the Constitution.

Advertise with us

The Senate has the right, and duty, to confirm or deny the nominee. That is in the same section. Theoretically, this could happen even closer to the election.

There is nothing in the Constitution that says a president should renounce this right because an election is near. An election is always somewhat near.

The Constitution also does not prohibit the Senate from failing to act on a nomination, as it did under the leadership of Mitch McConnell, when President Barack Obama nominated Merrick Garland in 2016, though it was a cheap trick. The senator was not acting out of any principle. He was simply doing what he knew he could get away with — a motive that may not have desecrated the Senate but surely did not lift it.

Democrats cannot win this fight because, this time, they don’t have the votes.

Moreover, they will lose the larger battle for political legitimacy if they simply engage in bullying and character assassination in the confirmation hearings.

Advertise with us

The real issue is not whether the president has the right to exercise his constitutional powers, but how we got to such a politicized Supreme Court nomination process and whether we can ever walk it back.

Through most of the last century these nominations, while political, were at least one step away from bare-knuckle ideological partisanship. Presidents nominated people of their own parties and the other party deferred. The understanding was that the deference went both ways — Republicans bowed to Democratic presidents and vice versa. Indeed, sometimes the confirmation vote was a voice vote.

The second condition (understood) was that the person be qualified.

The third was that the person would be in the legal and political mainstream.

And the fourth was that nominees would not be asked to promise how they would vote — no litmus tests on abortion, school prayer, flag burning, etc.

Advertise with us

This one-step-away-from-politics approach allowed justices to concentrate on the law and to often surprise the parties they came from and disappoint the presidents who nominated them.

Earl Warren, an ex-Republican governor, turned out to be a liberal jurist. Byron White, nominated by John F. Kennedy, was no liberal. John Paul Stevens, nominated by President Gerald Ford, started as a moderate and evolved into something very different.

The real issue is that we have so politicized the Supreme Court nomination process that we have forgotten the law. Our justices, increasingly, are people in an ideological box that they cannot and do not wish to escape. They cannot grow, as Hugo Black and John Marshall Harlan did. They cannot change as Justice Anthony Kennedy or Justice Harry Blackmun did. The only recent example of someone on the court who will let the law take him where his politics would never go is Neil Gorsuch.

Justice Blackmun was confirmed by a 94-0 vote. Justice Stevens by 98-0. Antonin Scalia by 98-0. Sandra Day O’Connor by 99-0. Ruth Bader Ginsburg by 96-3.

All this changed during the first Bush presidency and has only gotten worse since.

Advertise with us

Politics has always been a part of the process, of course, but it was never the only factor — overwhelming and almost obliterating almost all consideration of legal thought and reasoning.

When there was less contention and bitter, rigid partisanship we got a more open-minded and thoughtful court. And the Senate and the court were both allowed to retain a little of their dignity.