Looting, arson and vandalism are not cheap. The violent protests that have roiled America in the wake of George Floyd’s death could cost the insurance industry as much as $2 billion in paid claims. This according to Property Claim Services, a company that tracks claims related to civil disorder.

This summer’s damages have already eclipsed the prior record of $775 million in paid claims that resulted from the 1992 Los Angeles riots, when the police officers who savagely beat Rodney King were acquitted. Unlike in 1992, today’s protests are happening across the country, thus PCS has designated 2020’s unrest as a “multi-state catastrophe event.”

The real economic and psychological costs of such destruction and violence, however, are borne by real people.

In Kenosha, Wis., the latest American city to experience a devastating flare-up after the police shooting of Jacob Blake, 56 businesses were damaged or destroyed — at an estimated cost of $50 million — in two of Kenosha’s business districts.

Advertise with us

This includes the city’s Uptown neighborhood, which is lined with minority-owned businesses. “This has put us a generation back,” said Jan Michalski, the Kenosha alderman who represents Uptown. “After the unrest and rioting, half the buildings in the Uptown area are either badly damaged or completely unusable.”

In Minneapolis, the city in which this nationwide conflagration began, rioters set fire to 90% of the small businesses along the Lake Street corridor, many of which are minority owned. Further, a $30 million affordable-housing complex built to provide residences for poor residents of the city, many of them Black, was burned.

In their 2004 study, “The Labor Market Effects of the 1960s Riots,” authors William J. Collins and Robert A. Margo found a 9% decline in median Black family income in cities that experienced large-scale riots compared with cities that did not. In a second paper, “The Economic Aftermath of the 1960s Riots,” the authors concluded that the 1960s riots “depressed the median value of Black-owned property between 1960 and 1970, with little or no rebound in the 1970s.” Causing an estimated 10% loss in the total value of Black-owned residential property, the riots simply widened the racial gap in property values.

According to a Harris poll taken after the 1967 Detroit riots, 68% of Blacks characterized the looters as “criminals.” The same percentage said violence was counterproductive in the fight for civil rights.

This is in glaring contrast to the argument that author Vicky Osterweil makes in her book, “In Defense of Looting: A Riotous History of Uncivil Action.” NPR gave Ms. Osterweil a platform to inform listeners that riots and looting are more effective than peaceful protesting “at attracting attention to a cause.” The author calls looting a “joyous” experience that can produce “community cohesion” and should be seen as a “direct redistribution of wealth.”

Advertise with us

Naturally, NPR did not talk to people in poor neighborhoods to confirm that looting does indeed produce a gleeful solidarity, nor did the public media platform interview the small-business owners who saw their dreams reduced to cinders.

The insurance industry might have to pay up this year, but society at large, in the form of lasting economic devastation and increased racial polarization, will be paying for years to come.