On Facebook, Kyle Rittenhouse does not exist. When the 17-year-old was charged with killing two protesters and wounding another on the night of Aug. 25 in Kenosha, Wis., the social media conglomerate, acting as judge, jury and digital executioner, expunged Mr. Rittenhouse’s identity from its platform. His account was terminated, links to fundraising efforts for his legal defense were deleted, and searches for his name were blocked.
A Facebook spokesman defended its decision by saying “We don’t allow symbols, praise or support of dangerous individuals or organizations on Facebook.” The company removed posts “in support” of Mr. Rittenhouse because it considers the incident a “mass murder.”
The First Amendment imposes no limits on Facebook’s ability to choose what can exist on its platform. Determining who or what is dangerous is the company’s prerogative as a private entity; however, a strong case can also be made that Black Lives Matter is a dangerous organization if we consider the looting, vandalizing and destruction that has been exercised in the name of the movement. A strong case can also be made that the protesters who harassed citizens in Pittsburgh and Washington, D.C., among other cities, by screaming at them, forcing them to raise their fists and stealing drinks off their tables are dangerous individuals.
Furthermore, to categorize the Kenosha shootings as a “mass murder” is to place Mr. Rittenhouse in the same category as the men who have slaughtered people indiscriminately in places like El Paso, Texas, and Dayton, Ohio, last year. It is clear — though not on Facebook — that the Kenosha case is more complicated.
Mr. Rittenhouse’s legal team will argue that the teen was acting in self-defense. Video footage shows Mr. Rittenhouse running away from a crowd when someone fired a shot in the air, to which Mr. Rittenhouse turned and opened fire. One man tried to strike Mr. Rittenhouse with a skateboard, another man approached him carrying a pistol.
Facebook, the dominant medium of exchange for politics and current events in America, has made it clear that its extensive gate will be kept from anyone who wants to make a case in Mr. Rittenhouse’s defense, contradicting CEO Mark Zuckerberg’s repeated verbal commitments to protect free speech.
We want Facebook to block incitements to violence, not to prejudge defendants, and the company’s willingness to do so in this case is a dangerous and misguided attempt to tip the public opinion scales in favor of Mr. Rittenhouse’s conviction.
Yes, the defendant showed disastrously poor judgment in leaving his Illinois home and driving across state lines with a rifle to act as guardian of the peace; however, his guilt or innocence will be determined in court, not by Facebook’s censors.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.