Pittsburgh Mayor Bill Peduto is a man with a plan.
Or, at least, a plan to generate a plan.
Mr. Peduto recently announced that over the course of the next year, the city will collect feedback from residents in all 90 neighborhoods before developing policies and zoning regulations to guide the city’s economic evolution for the next 20 years.
This is a step along the road of the ForgingPGH Comprehensive Plan. ForgingPGH has concurrently released a “Conditions and Trends” report that provides the framework for the upcoming land use plan and spells out some of the city’s priorities for the coming decades.
It cites goals such as equity in life expectancy and economic status and redressing the disproportionate effects poor air and water quality have on nonwhite and low-income communities.
Thus far the plan presents no concrete plans or metrics to deal with such issues.
Presumably, if the city knew how to solve them it A) would already be doing so and B) would not be looking to residents to come up with fixes.
Additionally, the Pittsburgh of 20 years ago was completely different than the city today. How can any policy framework presume to dictate economic growth 20 years in the future?
The conditions and trends report also cites a 2019 Gender Equity Commission study that describes inequality of outcome based on gender and race in Pittsburgh with exacting detail, yet remains mysteriously nonspecific about causes and solutions.
That study alleges vaguely that systemic and institutional racism are largely at fault for current inequities but largely ignores other factors, such as high rates of single-parent households in the city. While historic oppression is undoubtedly still affecting lives today, pretending there are no other addressable cultural or environmental concerns is negligent gaslighting.
Pittsburgh’s residents know what needs to be fixed moving forward if residents are to enjoy a higher quality of life and if the city is to continue to attract and retain talent.
So does city government.
Leaders should start by improving the air quality. Addressing water quality. Looking to quality of education and college readiness. Public transportation. Homicide rates in the Black community. Homelessness.
These are issues that must be attended to by both communities and local government as Pittsburgh continues its transformation from capital of industry to health care and technological hot spot.
While listening to residents can and should inform some of the city’s policy decisions, taking a year to listen and formulate a 20-year strategy has the hollow ring of tilting at windmills. After all, the same man who has been leading the city these past six years is still trying to assess problems and priorities.
The city should focus its efforts on real improvements to quality of life on a realistic timetable and stop grandstanding against phantoms of institutionalized injustice.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.