Since early summer, police around the country have been enduring cutbacks, hiring freezes and higher rates of retirement.
While conversations about police reform should continue, this is not the time to blindly rush toward shrinking police departments. And yet, that’s exactly what’s been happening.
Hark back to May 30 when rioters vandalized 71 businesses in Downtown Pittsburgh. They smashed windows; ransacked stores; emptied cash registers; stole food, clothes and jewelry; set two police squad cars on fire; and threw lit Molotov cocktails at police, as well as bricks and stones.
Pittsburgh police attempted to stay the mob with professionalism and restraint. As reward for their efforts, City Council voted to freeze further officer hiring and shift $250,000 from their recruiting budget to fund social services programs, among other reforms.
The decision was not guided by prudence or foresight. It was an acquiescence to a nationwide trend of scapegoating the police for larger societal ills.
That same trend has resulted in the accelerated retirement of police around the country as a violent crime wave overtakes many of this country’s metropolitan areas this summer, up 24% among the 50 largest cities.
Conversations about reform and oversight must continue, but this is not the time to reduce police presence.
Calls to “defund” or reduce the police force fly in the face of strong polling evidence that a majority of Americans support maintaining or increasing police presence in their communities, while also reforming certain practices and protections.
In Pittsburgh, more than 280 officers are eligible for retirement this fall. It is not known how many will actually do so. The department currently has more than 1,000 officers and has budgeted for 900 in 2021. If numbers dip below that figure, some services will have to go.
Pittsburgh police Chief Scott Schubert said recruitment is down due to the city’s hiring freeze, negative public sentiment and the pandemic. The current class of recruits in training could be the last for a while, he warned.
Fraternal Order of Police Fort Pitt Lodge 1 President Robert Swartzwelder has cited consistent criticism from Mayor Bill Peduto and District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr. as factors as well.
Is it any wonder many police officers are questioning whether the job — a dangerous and demanding one — is worth it?
Elected leaders must make sure police have the funds and training they need to do their jobs effectively and should not continue to foster the current toxic atmosphere around the profession.
There are reasonable arguments to be made that the myriad duties of officers have overburdened police, and that their responsibilities should be scaled back. But doing this before other departments and systems are prepared to take up the slack would be premature and foolish.
Until there are defined strategies in place for the transfer of duties, the city should not diminish or demean its police. Fewer officers means longer response times, and fewer resources means poorer service and less training.
Leaders must not cave to illogical political pressures and do more to protect those sworn to protect the public.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.