In the early 19th century, one of the keenest observers of American life, French historian Alexis de Tocqueville, remarked that “the politics of America is the politics of the printed page.” For Americans of the 21st century, political organizing, political expression and the consumption of news takes place almost exclusively online, where the loudest, angriest and most-reductive voices are ascendant.

The face-to-face town hall democracy that Tocqueville so admired about America has been replaced by the remote democracy of social media, and this raises questions that the First Amendment was not structured to address. For example, does a public official have the right to block a follower on Twitter? President Donald Trump hopes the Supreme Court will answer in the affirmative.

On Aug. 20, the White House asked the highest court to restore the president’s power to block individual users from following his account, an act the lower courts said was in violation of First Amendment rights. The Knight First Amendment Institute, which brought the case on behalf of seven individuals whom Mr. Trump blocked in 2017, argues that a president’s personal Twitter handle is analogous to a town hall, where government officials are prohibited from preventing people from speaking.

There are many problems with this analogy, one being that users can set up fake accounts on Twitter while keeping their real identity anonymous. This is the equivalent of wearing a wig and mustache to an actual town hall meeting. Further, if you are an elected official and someone starts screaming at you in public you can walk away. The lower courts decided that there is no equivalent of walking away online. It’s like saying to the president, or a state senator, or a city council member that they must receive direct text messages from their constituents or else they’ll be sued.

Advertise with us

Those whom Mr. Trump has blocked are not prevented from reading his tweets, and, crucially, they are still free to tweet as much as they want. That’s why it’s unclear how speech is being restricted in this case. If Twitter was created and operated by the state, then this would indeed be an infringement of speech, but Twitter is a private company, and commenting on the platform is not the only means of expressing one’s opinions. Twitter is just one tributary in the vast watershed of ideas in American life.

It’s unclear why Mr. Trump, or any elected official at any level of government, should be denied a power that every other Twitter user possesses. Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, D-N.Y., blocked several users on Twitter last year, arguing that “they do not have the right to force others to endure their harassment and abuse.” Ms. Ocasio-Cortez was sued and apologized for blocking other users; however, this apology was unnecessary. She, like her political opposite Mr. Trump, and any other user on Twitter, should have access to the tools that insulate themselves from online harassment.

The First Amendment does not limit the privacy of elected officials, and access to public figures on their personal social media is not a constitutional right. Further, as Harvard law professor Noah Feldman put it, “A judicial decision forcing Twitter to make Trump unblock followers would actually violate Twitter’s First Amendment rights.”

The Supreme Court decided decades ago that citizens “have no constitutional right to force the government to listen to their views.” They ought to take this case and rule with the same wisdom.