Goodbye, Chicago boys. Hello, MIT gang.
The term “Chicago boys” refers to Latin American economists, trained at the University of Chicago, who took radical free-market ideology back to their home countries. Their influence was part of a broader phenomenon: The 1970s and 1980s were an era of ascendancy for laissez-faire economic ideas and the Chicago school, which promoted those ideas.
Now a different school is ascendant, and rightly so.
It’s really quite remarkable. Former Fed chair Ben Bernanke has a Ph.D. from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology; so do Mario Draghi, the president of the European Central Bank, and Olivier Blanchard, the influential chief economist of the International Monetary Fund. Mr. Blanchard is retiring, but his replacement, Maurice Obstfeld, is another MIT guy — and another student of Stanley Fischer, who taught at MIT for many years and is now the Fed’s vice chairman.
Many other MIT-trained economists, especially Ph.D.s from the 1970s, play an outsized role in policy discussion across the Western world. And yes, I’m part of the gang. But what distinguishes MIT economics and why does it matter?
Back in the 1970s, when all the people I’ve just named went to graduate school, the big issue was the combination of high unemployment with high inflation. The coming of stagflation was a big win for Chicago’s Milton Friedman, who had predicted exactly that outcome if the government tried to keep unemployment too low for too long; it was widely seen, mostly wrongly, as proof that markets get it right and the government should just stay out of the way.
At MIT, however, Keynesian economics never went away. To be sure, stagflation showed that there were limits to what policy can do. But students continued to learn about the imperfections of markets and how monetary and fiscal policy can boost a depressed economy.
The MIT students of the 1970s enlarged on those insights in their later work. Mr. Blanchard, for example, showed how small deviations from perfect rationality can have large economic consequences. Mr. Obstfeld showed that currency markets can sometimes experience self-fulfilling panic.
This open-minded, pragmatic approach was overwhelmingly vindicated after crisis struck in 2008. Chicago-school types warned incessantly that responding to the crisis by printing money and running deficits would lead to ’70s-type stagflation, with soaring inflation and interest rates. But MIT types predicted, correctly, that inflation and interest rates would stay low in a depressed economy, and that attempts to slash deficits too soon would deepen the slump.
The truth is that the economic analysis some of us learned at MIT way back when has worked very well for the past seven years.
But has the intellectual success of MIT economics led to comparable policy success? Unfortunately, no.
True, there have been important monetary successes. The Fed, led by Mr. Bernanke, ignored right-wing pressure — then-Texas Gov. Rick Perry accused him of treason — and pursued an aggressively expansionary policy that helped limit the damage from the financial crisis. In Europe, Mr. Draghi’s activism probably saved the euro from collapse.
On other fronts, however, the MIT gang’s good advice has been ignored. The IMF’s research department, under Mr. Blanchard’s leadership, has done authoritative work on the effects of fiscal policy, demonstrating beyond any reasonable doubt that slashing spending in a depressed economy is a terrible mistake, and that attempts to reduce high levels of debt via austerity are self-defeating. But European politicians have slashed spending and demanded crippling austerity from debtors anyway.
Meanwhile, in the United States, Republicans have responded to the failure of free-market orthodoxy and the successful predictions of much-hated Keynesians by digging in even deeper, determined to learn nothing from experience.
In other words, being right isn’t enough to change the world. But it’s still better to be right than to be wrong, and MIT-style economics, with its pragmatic openness to evidence, has been right indeed.
Paul Krugman is a syndicated columnist for The New York Times.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.