Jim Thorpe was said to be the greatest athlete of the 20th century. Today, this is mostly observed by sports historians, not casual sports fans. To the extent that his faded fame endures, it is because of places like Jim Thorpe, Pa., a borough named after him in an agreement to make it his final resting place.

A man of exceptional talent, he won gold medals in two of the toughest Olympic events — the decathlon and pentathlon, at the 1912 games. (His medals were later taken away because he had allegedly violated the amateur code by playing semi-pro baseball, only to be restored posthumously 70 years later.) He also was a football pioneer and is enshrined in the Pro Football Hall of Fame.

He was remarkable in life. Of part Native American descent, he grew up poor in Oklahoma and was educated at Carlisle Indian Industrial School in Carlisle, Pa. But lately he has been remarkable in death.

After all his great athletic deeds, he died at age 64 in 1953 and his third wife, Patricia, made a deal with a couple of obscure communities in Carbon County, Pa.: They would merge and be called Jim Thorpe if the great athlete was buried there.

Advertise with us

Although he never visited while alive, his honored tomb has been there ever since. It may remain so after a Third Circuit of the U.S. Court of Appeals ruling on Thursday. Years after the internment, his sons sued to have his remains returned to Oklahoma to rest with the Sac and Fox Nation, his tribe. A federal judge at first agreed under the terms of the 1990 Native American Grave Protection and Repatriation Act, an important tool in stopping desecration.

Except this burial was not a desecration; it was and is an honoring — which the appeals court recognized. Applying the act in this case was “clearly an absurd result,” it said. So, barring further appeal, Jim Thorpe rests in the honored place he was buried, serving the good cause of keeping his fame unburied.