Putting people first. That's one of the marketing themes of Highmark insurance as it prepares customers for the Jan. 1 divorce from the UPMC health system.
The message rings hollow, however, and you don't have to take our word for it. It’s the view of the state attorney general, insurance commissioner and health secretary, all of whom have taken Highmark to court on a claim that it’s violating a consent decree that the insurer, the state agencies and UPMC reached over the summer.
The state wants Commonwealth Court to find Highmark in contempt of the consent decree for marketing a Medicare Advantage policy that provides no access to UPMC doctors. Highmark began offering the policy last week for the incredibly low premium of zero dollars, just after it had jacked up the monthly premiums on Medicare Advantage policies that do provide in-network UPMC access. Most of those premiums rose by double-digit percentages, one doubled and another tripled.
All this after Highmark fought for years to maintain in-network access to UPMC for its customers. Now the region’s top insurer has its own hospital system, the Allegheny Health Network, and this pricing strategy seems aimed at driving as many older policy holders as possible to Highmark’s hospitals and doctors.
The Pittsburgh region benefits from competition between hospital systems, just as it does from competition between insurers, but it should not come at the expense of onerous pricing for seniors. That subverts Highmark’s assurance of UPMC access for Medicare customers.
Highmark disagrees and has counter-sued state regulators, saying the no-premium, no-UPMC plan was approved by the federal Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services and that “seniors could reap the benefit of a lower cost product that may better suit their needs.”
That may be a fine legal argument, but it doesn't pass the smell test.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.