As the Jan. 1 separation of UPMC health care and Highmark health insurance approaches, their dealings with each other should become more clear. Instead, a new development has muddied the water, leaving customers more confused.
Not long ago, Highmark fought to give as many of its customers, post-2014, as much affordable access to UPMC health facilities and physicians as possible. As a result, a consent decree signed in July by the two organizations and state officials made sure that, among other things, Medicare customers insured by Highmark plans would have in-network access to UPMC.
Then, last week, Highmark unveiled a Medicare Advantage plan that charges zero premium but allows no UPMC access. Highmark offers other plans to seniors, however, that do charge a premium and do provide UPMC service.
On the other half of the divide, UPMC, which will keep out most Highmark customers beginning next year, cried foul because it wants to keep Highmark’s Medicare customers in (go figure). More important, the state insurance commissioner, state attorney general and state health secretary agree that Highmark’s marketing of the no-premium, no-UPMC plan violates the consent decree.
If this is the new path to health care competition, we’re in for a bumpy ride.
It was only last week that the Post-Gazette called on state regulators to jump back into the fray on behalf of greater customer clarity and fairness. They did and gave a tongue-lashing to UPMC and Highmark in letters sent last weekend:
“We are extremely disappointed that both companies appear to have lost sight of the spirit in which you entered the consent decree ...”
With that, state officials may have put their finger on the problem. If more attention were paid by Highmark and UPMC to the spirit of the decree than the letter, they might better help their customers cope with change.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.