This is the first in a series of candidate endorsements for contested races in the Nov. 4 election. The Post-Gazette will publish a recap of its recommendations on Sunday, Nov. 2.

The race in the state’s 45th House District offers voters a choice between a dependable, somewhat conservative six-term Democrat and a Republican with a libertarian bent who was recently a Democrat.

Rep. Nick Kotik, 63, of Kennedy, has been concerned about equitable funding for education and supports a possible way to raise revenues — through an extraction tax on Marcellus Shale drillers. He favors, however, a hybrid extraction tax married to the existing impact fee, because municipalities have come to depend on it, and he would not want the tax to be too high.

Mr. Kotik, a former municipal manager of Robinson, disapproves of this year’s state budget, which he dismisses as “all smoke and mirrors.” While a pro-life social conservative, he respects the court ruling that legalized gay marriage in Pennsylvania and supports House Bill 300 that would outlaw employment discrimination against gays.

Advertise with us

Republican challenger Benjamin Gross, a corporate attorney from Rosslyn Farms, is mostly in sync with these social views. He too describes himself as pro-life and supports gay marriage and workplace equality. He favors full legalization of marijuana, going further than Mr. Kotik, who is a supporter only of medical use of marijuana.

Like Mr. Kotik, Mr. Gross, 45, wants to see the equitable distribution of education funds to rich and poor districts, but his inclination would be to vote no on an extraction tax, worrying that the consumer would have to pay the price and drilling jobs might go to Ohio.

Before moving to this area in 2011, Mr. Gross was elected as a Democrat to the Lansdale, Pa., council, which he served as a president, and worked on the Obama campaign. He changed his party registration in 2010 because he opposed the president’s war policies.

The 45th District includes Carnegie, Pennsbury, Rosslyn Farms, Stowe, Kennedy, Robinson, Emsworth, Neville Island, Coraopolis, Ben Avon, Ben Avon Heights, Kilbuck and part of Scott.

The diversity of communities in the district requires an experienced lawmaker fully versed on the issues in Harrisburg. For that reason the Post-Gazette endorses Nick Kotik.