It was big news — and good news — six years ago when U.S. Steel Corp. sought and received from the Allegheny County Health Department a permit to begin a $1.2 billion coke oven replacement at its Clairton works.

Trouble is, the people nearby, who breathe some of the region’s most polluted air, are still waiting to reap the full benefit.

Not that positive things haven’t already happened. Jobs at the plant which employs about 1,300 have been preserved. Harmful emissions are way down. The air monitor in that part of the Monongahela Valley is in compliance with federal standards on fine-particle pollution.

But the costly and historic upgrade hasn’t delivered on all its promise yet. A 16-page consent order and agreement between the health department and U.S. Steel hits the company with a $300,000 civil penalty for routinely exceeding charging emissions limits at its new 84-oven C Battery.

Advertise with us

A county health official said the excess emissions amount to less than 10 tons a year, whereas overall pollution from the mile-long plant is down by hundreds of tons since the coke oven replacement. Even so, the county is right to be vigilant on clean air standards and on getting full compliance from U.S. Steel.

Although the agreement stipulates that the company “does not affirmatively admit the allegations of violations,” it doesn’t contest them either. The order will impose additional fines if the corrective actions required of the plant are not met by certain deadlines. That’s as it should be.

What also should be is a public and transparent process. Although the consent order was dated Aug. 7, it was released publicly last Wednesday only after questions from the Post-Gazette. The environmental group Citizens for Pennsylvania’s Future was right to fault the health department for not publicizing the agreement with a notice or presenting a draft to the public for input.

In a case like this, county residents appreciate the watchfulness of county officials. But the public also deserves a seat at the table, particularly in matters of life and breath.