Early Thursday, as news broke of a massive multinational prisoner swap deal involving four Americans, Marc Fogel called his sister from a Russian penal colony in Rybinsk.

At the time, it was unclear whether Mr. Fogel would be among the four.

What was clear was that the Oakmont teacher — who has been held since his 2021 arrest for marijuana possession in Moscow — was desperate to return home, said Sasha Phillips, an attorney representing Mr. Fogel’s family.

“Marc said, ‘If I’m left behind, my soul is going to be dead,’ or something along those lines,” Ms. Phillips told the Post-Gazette.

Advertise with us

Ms. Phillips said the crushing reality the family had dreaded was confirmed when two planes left Russia, and Mr. Fogel was calling from the prison.

“Everybody’s heart sank,” she said. “It was like a zigzag, back and forth. We get hope. The hope is dashed.”

Now, the road ahead remains unclear for Mr. Fogel, who turned 63 last week and whose health has been deteriorating each year he’s been held in the penal colony.

“He’s heartbroken and completely devastated,” Ms. Phillips said. “The worst part about this, the worst torture is not knowing, the anticipation and anxiety.”

Mr. Fogel has a degenerative spinal condition that has left him with significant muscle atrophy and a loss of sensation in his left arm and right leg. He has difficulty walking, especially on uneven surfaces, she said.

Advertise with us

Meanwhile, Mr. Fogel has over a decade left of his 14-year sentence and continues to cycle in and out of the hospital.

“When we say we’re afraid that this 14-year sentence could be a death sentence, we’re not exaggerating,” Ms. Phillips said. “We’re not being overly dramatic. He just got back from the hospital. That’s his third stay in a half a year.”

But his family and attorneys said they will keep working to bring him home.

To do so, they said it is imperative for the federal government to consider Mr. Fogel to be “wrongfully detained,” which was the case for Wall Street Journal reporter Evan Gershkovich and Paul Whelan, a Michigan corporate security executive. Both were part of last week’s swap.

Under the Robert Levinson Hostage Recovery and Hostage-Taking Accountability Act, there are resources for U.S. nationals imprisoned abroad, Ms. Phillips said.

Advertise with us

That includes financial support, legal and consular assistance, and regular reports to Congress on the status of the cases – but only if the person imprisoned is determined to be wrongfully detained.

In June, Mr. Fogel's mother, Malphine Fogel, wrote in a lawsuit against the federal government that she has been given no explanation as to why her son has not received the declaration when his case parallels that of so many other Americans who have, including WNBA star Brittney Griner, who was released in a 2022 swap.

“It’s just so unfair and it’s unfair that they didn’t give him a designation a long time ago,” Ms. Fogel, 95, told the Post-Gazette in her Butler home last week.

The lack of information about the conditions where her son is imprisoned has also been tormenting.

“I don’t know if they have hot water or a toothbrush,” she said. “I don’t know anything, but he [Marc] would never complain to me, particularly about conditions.”

Advertise with us

Ms. Phillips said if Mr. Fogel were to be given the wrongfully detained status, a coordinator would be assigned to his case to keep his family informed.

“It keeps a family from going through this hell of not knowing what’s happening to their loved ones,” Ms. Phillips said. “That’s one of the reasons we have been pushing for the wrongfully detained designation.”

Experts said that designation will be crucial for Mr. Fogel’s chances of returning home.

Bryan Stern, a Purple Heart recipient and combat veteran, has overseen the rescue of nearly 7,000 people from perilous situations in war-torn countries, as well as several hostages from Russia.

Mr. Stern, chairman of the nonprofit Grey Bull Rescue organization, said though Mr. Fogel’s family remains in the dark about the conditions he is living in, he has first-hand experience with Russian prisons.

Advertise with us

“They’re fortresses filled with prison guards, an infirmary, a half-baked hospital with poor food, poor treatment, cold water, not hot showers,” he said. “None of these places are good … you’re not being singled out because you’re an American, although being an American in a Russian jail does not make you any friends.”

Mr. Stern also said prisoner swaps — like the one executed last week that set some two dozen people free — are incredibly complex.

“The amount of moving pieces that went into this operation, the logistics alone, is a Herculean effort, and that’s a really big victory here,” he said. “I can say with the utmost certainty that there are terms and conditions of this deal that will never be made public and that’s the way it should be.”

Mr. Stern urged Mr. Fogel’s family to not let disappointment hamper efforts to bring him home.

“No. 1 is, don’t give up hope,” Mr. Stern said. “Do not give up hope and do anything. Talk to anyone, anyone that may be able to help … it’s amazing how something or someone that doesn’t really matter might actually be the person to break the logjam.”