This week, Russian officials began implementing a planned ban on the popular messaging platform Telegram after the company refused to hand over access to its users’ encrypted messages. But it appears the implementation of the ban is not going as smoothly as Russian authorities had hoped.

Media regulator Roskomnadzor (the Russian equivalent to the Federal Communications Commission in the US) began implementing the ban on Monday. A court in Moscow cleared the way for the ban last week, ruling that the company’s founder failed to comply with legislation that required the company to hand over users’ encrypted messages to Russia’s Federal Security Service (FSB).

Writing on his Telegram channel on Tuesday, Telegram founder and CEO Pavel Durov downplayed the impact of the ban and pledged to create workarounds for users who want to continue accessing the platform.

“Despite the ban, we haven’t seen a significant drop in user engagement so far,” Mr. Durov wrote, adding that Russians are bypassing restrictions through the use of virtual private networks and proxy servers.

Advertise with us

Mr. Durov added that his company has moved some of its infrastructure to third-party cloud servers “to remain partly available for our users [in Russia].” That appears to be why millions of IP addresses belonging to Amazon Web Services and Google Cloud were blocked on Tuesday. Services linked to Microsoft were also taken down, according to the Moscow Times.

The companies did not respond to a request for comment on whether they plan to continue hosting Telegram.

Read More

Retailers, online games and other web-based services, including the messaging app Viber, also saw their services affected because of the broadly enforced crackdown, according to the BBC. Indeed, Russia’s communications watchdog was locked in an intensive game of whack-a-mole on Wednesday with Telegram as its stuttering attempts to block the service inadvertently knocked out the websites of scores of small businesses.

Alexander Zharov, the head of the watchdog agency, Roskomnadzor, acknowledged that it had obstructed millions of IP addresses in an attempt to shutter Telegram (described by some as “carpet bombing” the internet to get after one small company). Roskomnadzor took that step after the company declined to provide encryption information, which would enable the agency to identify users and see the content of messages.

Roskomnadzor’s clumsy, unprecedented effort to follow through after being granted authority to block the app Friday caused a widespread outcry after the unintended consequences became apparent.

Advertise with us

A member of the band Pussy Riot organized a small public protest. Edward Snowden, the former N.S.A. contractor who leaked American surveillance documents and now lives in Russia, expressed support for the company. Even some usually staunch Kremlin supporters called the ban misguided.

As part of the effort to ban Telegram, Russian officials have also asked Google and Apple to remove Telegram from their app stores, Reuters reports.

PRI reached out to both companies for comment on how they plan to respond to the reported request, but did not receive a timely response.

In his statement Tuesday, Mr. Durov praised those and other US-based tech companies for “not taking part in political censorship.”

Russian authorities say they need access to the messaging data of those who use online services, including Telegram, for counterterrorism purposes. (In 2016, Russia passed a package of anti-terrorism measures — the so-called Yarovaya law — that effectively granted Russia’s security services the right to demand access to encrypted services.)

Advertise with us

For his part, the 33-year-old Mr. Durov has long held that complete user privacy is a priority. "I think that privacy, ultimately, and our right for privacy is more important than our fear of bad things happening, like terrorism,” Mr. Durov said back in 2015, when questioned about how the terrorist group ISIS was using the platform, and what he saw as his responsibility to act. “Ultimately ISIS will always find the way to communicate within themselves. And if communication ends up being not secure for them, they’ll switch to another [app] ... I think we’re … doing the right thing — protecting our users’ privacy.”

On Tuesday this week, Mr. Durov stood firmly by that sentiment, writing in his statement, “We promised our users 100% privacy and would rather cease to exist than violate this promise.”

Internet rights activists in Russia and beyond have praised Mr. Durov’s firm and consistent stance on user privacy. The CEO even got a shoutout Tuesday from NSA contractor-turned-whistleblower Edward Snowden on Twitter.

The Russian government’s move to block the platform appeared to be — at least initially — largely unsuccessful, with users reporting on Tuesday they were still able to use the app, a full 24 hours into the ban’s announced implementation. Still, some say enforcing the ban sets a new precedent for online censorship in Russia.

“If you have a government agency being so brutal attacking Telegram, taking down millions of IP addresses, after that you can do what you want,” said Andrei Soldatov, one of the authors of “The Red Web,” a history of the Russian internet. “After they have faced this much heat, they can go after Facebook and Google.”

Advertise with us

Internet experts suggest that what the Kremlin really wants is leverage to order the internet platforms to remove things that it does not like.

“They want a hotline that they can pick up to call someone to do something,” said Mr. Soldatov. “It is a very Soviet approach.”

Others in the country worry the move sends a negative signal to homegrown tech and other talent in Russia.

“Durov was an inspiration for me personally and for my generation,” says Andrey Mima, the founder of a St. Petersburg startup and a former employee of VKontakte, another company Mr. Durov founded. “We are sad about our future and … being in St. Petersburg and understanding that we cannot do big things and create some influential web service or some tool that won’t be, in some way, suppressed by the government.”

Mr. Durov, a Russian native who lives in self-imposed exile abroad, is widely admired by Russia’s youth and those in the country’s tech scene.

Advertise with us

Before founding Telegram in 2013, Mr. Durov launched Vkontakte (or VK) a social media website often likened to the Facebook of Russia. Mr. Durov left the wildly successful platform and fled the country following clashes with Russian authorities. The company is now under the control of one of Russian President Vladimir Putin’s allies.

Telegram representatives have previously said they would appeal a ruling immediately blocking the platform in Russia.

According to figures released last month, Telegram currently has 14 million users in Russia — making up about 7 percent of nearly 200 users worldwide.

Among the countless victims of Telegram’s ban is a small Moscow-based education project which uses the app’s bot platform to engage users in tasks and foster creative thinking.

Solomon Shlosman, co-founder of the MOST Creative Camp, said Wednesday he set out “to do something good for my country and to contribute to people living here, but they — the government — are preventing me from doing this. Blocking is what they did in the Soviet times and now they are doing it again.”

Advertise with us

To Nikita Likachyov, editor-in-chief of the Russian online tech magazine T Journal, the Telegram ban is a watershed moment for the Russian internet community. Public reaction to the ban will show if the community can come up with “successful counter-measures against the decision,” Mr. Likachyov said.

How effective the government is in blocking Telegram can determine the future of other social media platforms.

“If they go full house on Telegram, it means they can go full house on YouTube and Facebook,” he said.

But, Mr. Likachyov says, the fact that the rebel messaging app is still up and running shows that government agencies are not competent enough to enforce the ban.

“The government has put so much pressure on trying to get control of the internet and still it doesn’t understand how it works — in terms of the spirit and freedom. You cannot tame that beast, and we don’t want to give it up,” he said.

Advertise with us

Elsewhere, Iran seemed to be following Moscow’s lead, with news agencies reporting on Wednesday that it would ban government organizations from using foreign-based messaging services including Telegram, which is extremely popular in the Islamic Republic. More than 40 million Iranians use Telegram, which played an important role in spreading information about antigovernment protests in December and January.

The office of the supreme leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, an active Telegram user, said he had shut down his account to set the example. The decision was “in line with safeguarding national interests and removing the monopoly of the Telegram messaging app,” the ayatollah’s last Telegram stated, according to Iran’s government-run Press TV news website.

The Associated Press and The New York Times contributed.