NEW DELHI - India announced on Thursday a program to give half-a-billion citizens at least partial coverage under health insurance, a potentially transformative upgrade of the country’s dilapidated public health care services and a key element of the Narendra Modi government’s last budget before national elections next year.
If the ambitious new plan, dubbed “Modicare” by Indian media, is approved by Parliament and adequately funded and implemented, it could represent a first step toward universal health coverage, according to Finance Minister Arun Jaitley - a development that would be life-changing in a country where millions of people still rely for treatment on village quacks and ascetic healers.
But economists are asking how such a vast program can be funded in just a year.
Under the plan, the government will cover health care costs of up to $7,800 for 100 million poor families and spend some $188 million to create “health and wellness” centers, Jaitley announced to loud table-thumping in India’s lower house. Spending on nutrition for tuberculosis patients, cleanliness drives and education will also result in significant improvements in public health, he said.
“This will be the world’s largest government-funded health care program,” Jaitley told lawmakers.
Many health experts reacted positively to the plan. “This is a very proactive budget,” said Vinay Aggarwal, former president of the Indian Medical Association. “Before this, hardly 5 percent of Indians were covered by health insurance. If you take into account private health care, it’s hardly 10 percent. Now we’re addressing 45 percent,” he said, adding that the proposed coverage of $7,800 per family represents a very large amount in India, where spending on health care is much lower than in the United States.
India currently spends 1.4 percent of its gross domestic product on health care compared with China’s 3.1 percent and the United States’ 8.3 percent, according to the World Bank. Average life expectancy is 68, compared with 76 in China and 78 in the United States. In the absence of government help, 7 percent of Indians fell below the poverty line between 2004 and 2014 because of health care costs alone, according to a report by Brookings India.
A string of tragedies in recent years has underscored the scope of the country’s health care crisis. In the state of Gorakhpur in August, 60 children died after a government hospital ran out of oxygen supplies. In the state of Chhattisgarh in 2014, 15 women died in botched sterilization operations.
Economists estimate that the new program will cost many billions of dollars - money not accounted for in the finance minister’s broad allocations. “How they’re going to pay for this is puzzling all of us,” said Dipa Sinha, professor of economics at Ambedkar University in New Delhi.
Jaitley did not give a breakdown of proposed health care spending or a total for how much the various elements of the new plan would cost, although he did introduce a health and education surtax that the Finance Ministry anticipates will raise around $1.7 billion next year. The detailed plan is expected to be laid out in Parliament in the coming days.
Jaitley’s “people-friendly” budget is being seen by analysts in India as a pre-election effort to woo voters, who last year bore the twin economic shocks of Modi’s demonetization initiative and a goods and services tax.
Sinha note that a previous health care program introduced in 2016 by Modi’s government never got funding.
“Going by their own past record, there’s no way this can happen in a year,” she said.
“Modicare” was just one of the populist giveaways announced Thursday.
Speaking in Parliament, Jaitley also announced a liberalization of agricultural exports, which will increase from $30 billion a year to $100 billion, to help push up crop prices for farmers. Exports of many agricultural products have long been restricted by regulations.
The government will also help build more than 5 million affordable houses for the poor in the next financial year, which goes from April 1 to March 31.
India’s stock market took a hit after Jaitley announced a 10 percent tax on some long-term capital gains, saying stock market returns were “quite attractive and it was time to bring them under the ambit of capital gains tax.”
He also said 80 million women would be given free connections for liquefied cooking gas, which cost about $45 apiece, and 40 million poor families would get free electricity connections, which cost $12-$20.
He announced no changes for personal income tax rates.
“This is an election budget,” said M.S. Unnikirishnan of the Confederation of Indian Industry, a powerful trade group. “It’s good at the macro level with the government keeping the fiscal deficit at 3.5 percent of the gross domestic product.” India’s economy totals $2.5 trillion.
The Associated Press contributed.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.