Friday, July 25, 2025, 7:45PM | 
MENU
Advertisement
In this Jan. 1 file photo, Gunnar Johansen, left,  and Trond Dalgard fish for cod in the Norwegian Sea near Gryllefjord, Norway.
1
MORE

What Britain can learn from Norway as it weighs life outside European Union

Cornelius Poppe/NTB scanpix via AP

What Britain can learn from Norway as it weighs life outside European Union

Ahead of a June 23 referendum on whether to quit the EU, Britons are looking across the North Sea to oil-rich Norway for clues on what life could be like outside the bloc

STAVANGER, Norway — Ahead of a June 23 referendum on whether to quit the European Union, Britons are looking across the North Sea to Norway for clues on what life could be like outside the bloc.

The oil-rich Norwegians clearly have done OK. A free-trade deal ensures they enjoy almost the same access to the union’s giant market as had they been EU members. But to keep those trade ties smooth, Norway has had to adopt most EU directives, without having a say when they were decided.

Here’s a look at the advantages and disadvantages Norway has faced from staying outside the union.

Advertisement

Trade

Norway, Iceland and Liechtenstein belong to a small club of non-members that enjoy access to the EU’s huge single market, because they have signed up to the European Economic Area agreement. The relationship is economically fruitful: Some 84 percent of Norwegian exports go to the EU, and 62 percent of its imports are from the bloc.

For Britain to join this club it would have to accept four EU-style freedoms: free movement of goods, services, people and capital. Also, Norway implements more than three-quarters of all EU laws without having a formal way of influencing how they’re drafted.

That is the opposite of what the supporters of a British exit from the EU, or Brexit, want.

Advertisement

“It is not just that we don’t influence the rules, we don’t understand why we have them. Rather than being involved in drafting new rules, we have to spend time asking what the last one was all about,” says Paal Frisvold, a Norwegian who is managing director of Geelmuyden Kiese Brussels, a lobbying firm for Scandinavian companies.

Immigration

After the 2004 EU expansion into Eastern Europe, Polish plumbers came to symbolize the arrival of cheap labor into British towns. Supporters say Britain has benefited from their arrival, citing studies showing EU migrants contribute more to British coffers in tax than they take out through benefits. Critics argue their arrival puts a strain on housing and services and keeps a lid on wages, penalizing poorer Britons.

Whatever the merits, following Norway’s example on this issue wouldn’t satisfy the concerns of the supporters of a British EU exit, as Norway has more EU migrants than Britain relative to population size. That’s because Norway has signed on to the EEA, and unlike Britain, it’s a member of Europe’s passport-free Schengen zone, which makes it easier to enter Norway than Britain.

Farming

Norway is not part of the EU’s Common Agricultural Policy, which subsidizes farmers and guarantees tariff-free trade across borders. The share of the EU budget earmarked for agriculture has fallen from 73 percent in 1980 to around 40 percent today but the policy remains a bugbear for many Brits who bristle at propping up the rural lifestyle of French and Polish farmers.

Oslo does not subsidize foreign agriculture. But tariffs for EU produce are high, which feeds through to pricey supermarket bills. And what Norway saves in EU subsidies is more than offset by lavish support to its own farmers. According to the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development, subsidies account for more than 60 percent of their income. British farmers fear their government would not be so generous. Supporters of a so-called Brexit argue it should be up to Britain to decide.

Fisheries

Norway doesn’t have to share its lucrative fishing waters with EU nations. The Common Fisheries Policy, which divvies up European waters and sets limits on how many fish can be caught, was a big reason why the seafaring country voted “no” to EU membership in 1972 and 1994.

Plentiful stocks of cod and other white fish suggest it can happily manage its own waters.

Fishermen in northern Norway say the industry supports many small coastal communities that would have struggled if they had to compete with foreign trawlers in their own waters.

“Maybe nothing would be left for these small societies,” said Paul Jensen, a fisherman from the village of Ersfjordbotn. “Only snow and ice and skiing.”

But being outside the EU also means Norway has to pay tariffs to sell its fish to European consumers. The tariffs ratchet up for smoked or other treated products. So Norwegian fish farmers often choose to export untreated salmon to EU member Poland and smoke it there instead.

Foreign policy

Norway felt the sting of being alone when China punished it for the Norwegian Nobel Committee’s decision to award the Nobel Peace Prize to Chinese dissident Liu Xiaobo in 2010.

Even though the government has no say over the independent panel’s choices, work on a trade deal was suspended, visiting diplomats were humiliated, and Norwegian salmon faced sudden restrictions at Chinese docks.

Had Norway been part of the EU, Beijing could have faced retaliatory measures from the entire bloc. Being on its own meant it had to suck it up.

As a bigger country and permanent member of the U.N. Security Council, Britain has more clout on the world stage. But leaving the EU would mean losing its seat at the table when important issues are discussed in Brussels.

This has happened to Norway during the standoff between Russia and Ukraine or the free trade deal that the EU is negotiating with the U.S.

First Published: June 5, 2016, 4:00 a.m.

RELATED
Comments Disabled For This Story
Partners
Advertisement
An aerial view of Hersheypark.
1
news
9-year-old dies in incident at The Boardwalk in Hersheypark
Gov. Josh Shapiro appeared on “The Late Show with Stephen Colbert” Thursday and talked a lot about Pennsylvania, President Donald Trump, and the arson attack on the governor's residence in Harrisburg in April.
2
news
Gov. Shapiro tells Stephen Colbert that Trump has 'abandoned' Pennsylvanians
David Mielnicki, left, and Debbie and Jerry Santucci, owners of Cafe Notte in Emsworth.
3
life
Cafe Notte sharpens its focus after transformation via a major TV makeover show
The 11 Stanwix building Downtown on Sunday, March 3, 2024.
4
business
Brunner joins office shuffle as more companies leave Downtown for the North Shore
Pittsburgh Steelers linebackers T.J. Watt and Alex Highsmith (56) warm up during the NFL football team's training camp in Latrobe, Pa., Thursday, July 24, 2025.
5
sports
Christopher Carter's Steelers chat transcript: 07.25.25
In this Jan. 1 file photo, Gunnar Johansen, left, and Trond Dalgard fish for cod in the Norwegian Sea near Gryllefjord, Norway.  (Cornelius Poppe/NTB scanpix via AP)
Cornelius Poppe/NTB scanpix via AP
Advertisement
LATEST news
Advertisement
TOP
Email a Story