A Western Pennsylvania teenager suspected of killing his mother with a knife at a resort in India admitted to authorities there that the two got into a fight at their hotel but told police he did not kill her.

Joncarlo Patton, 15, had scratch marks over his body as a result of that fight, said police subinspector B.L. Ghayal of the Rural Jodhpur police.

The teenager from South Fayette was arrested Saturday, a day after he was detained at an airport while trying to board a flight to Delhi.

He was accused of killing his mother, Cindy Iannarelli, 51, of South Fayette, a business consultant and educator. The two were visiting Reggie's Camel Camp, a luxury tent resort in the historic town of Osian in the western Indian state of Rajasthan when Dr. Iannarelli was killed, her throat slit with a knife, on Friday.

Advertise with us

Joncarlo is scheduled to appear before a magistrate on Monday for a bail hearing, which will determine whether he will be allowed out of a juvenile facility where he is being held.

Inspector Ghayal gave this account of what happened, based on statements from the teen and from the police investigation.

On Thursday, Joncarlo and Dr. Iannarelli had dinner and drinks at the hotel resort with other Americans. Between 10 and 10:30 p.m., they returned to their hotel room, where they got into an argument over Dr. Iannarelli's divorce from Joncarlo's father, Richard Patton of Bridgeville.

Joncarlo was scheduled to attend school in Italy, but wanted to return home to live with his father, Inspector Ghayal said.

Later in the evening, Joncarlo ordered a banana and a knife from hotel staff, which was delivered to their room, which police believe was used in the attack.

Advertise with us

"He planned to get the knife from them, because he did not have it himself," Inspector Ghayal said. "He wanted to get that knife only for using it for the murder..."

Early Friday morning, police believe Dr. Iannarelli was attacked in her bed. Police found blood all over the hotel room, including a large pool of blood in a bathroom.

Dr. Iannarelli's body was found wrapped in a sheet in a sand dune. Her throat had been slit. An autopsy was conducted in the presence of a four-member team from the U.S. embassy in New Delhi, and her body is being returned to family in the Bridgeville area.

As of Monday, no members of the Iannarelli or Patton families had arrived in India, but U.S. officials looking into the incident have met with Joncarlo and were monitoring legal developments.

Legal authorities have said that if Joncarlo is tried, it would be in the local Indian courts. If it is proved he committed the crime, he would be subject to punishment in accordance with Indian law, which might not be severe in view of his age and circumstances.

Advertise with us

According to Inspector Ghayal, his trial could last from three to six months and he would face a maximum of three years in a juvenile facility.

He said there are no plans to extradite Joncarlo to the U.S.

It is not clear when Dr. Iannarelli told Joncarlo of her plans to have him spend the coming school year studying in Italy. The Iannarelli family is from Italy and has traveled there frequently for extended periods of time. Joncarlo spoke Italian.

Dr. Iannarelli, a teacher and business consultant, also wrote a weekly column for the Post-Gazette that appeared in 1995 and 1996.

South Fayette school Superintendent Billie Rondinelli said Monday that Dr. Iannarelli withdrew Joncarlo from school at the end of the school year in June. South Fayette requires students to withdraw if they are going to be away for more than two consecutive weeks because the district cannot provide education during that time.

Advertise with us

But at a friend's birthday party just a few weeks ago, Joncarlo, who was a member of the school's cross country team, said he wasn't enrolled for the first semester because "his family hadn't gotten around to it."

Dr. Iannarelli's mother, Dolores O. Iannarelli, 78, of Bridgeville, said her daughter and Joncarlo's father maintained a good relationship in recent years. They shared time with their son.

But court documents indicate that the split between Dr. Patton and Dr. Iannarelli was troubled. In particular, a 2003 e-mail between the couple stated that the relationship between the two had taken a toll on Joncarlo, who was 7 when his parents separated in September 2002.

Stating the circumstances of their separation in a handwritten court document, Dr. Iannarelli wrote, "Domestic Abuse and Criminal Charge." Both Dr. Iannarelli and Dr. Patton filed Protection from Abuse petitions that month, each attempting to exclude the other from the house they shared in Presto, a section of Collier.

On Sept. 3, 2002, Dr. Patton was arrested by Collier police and charged with simple assault, a count he pleaded guilty to in 2003.

Advertise with us

In the 2003 e-mail, reproduced in a court document filed by Dr. Patton, Dr. Iannarelli urged Dr. Patton to compromise on a custody arrangement for Joncarlo outside of the court system, "and avoid yet another painful situation for JC."

Referring to a program that Joncarlo had been invited to attend during a weekend he was to spend with his father, Dr. Iannarelli wrote: "This seems to me to just be the first issue of many events that will come up in the next ten years where he wants to participate and a ridgid [sic] custody schedule and difficult relationship between his parents will make it impossible. The result will be more internal problems and anger within JC that will last a lifetime."

Dr. Iannarelli sent the e-mail several months before her divorce from Dr. Patton was finalized. She asked him to set aside 20 minutes each day to discuss the issues affecting custody of their son.

"Yes, this is very painful in many ways for each of us and it seems easier to avoid it all and let other people decide who is right but the person suffering the most is JC and we as parents should step up to eliminate his pain sooner rather than later," she wrote.

In an e-mail Monday, Dr. Patton declined to comment about Joncarlo's case.