City leaders say that last week’s powerful storm has shown the need for more proactive weather-related planning in Pittsburgh, and Mayor Ed Gainey signed an executive order Thursday that he said is the first step in that process.
The executive order directs Pittsburgh’s top emergency adviser and city planner to “establish a mitigation plan to better prepare the city for increasingly severe, increasingly frequent storms resulting from climate change.”
Mr. Gainey said the order builds on a hazard mitigation plan that the administration began drafting earlier this year to address threats ranging from fires to train derailments to landslides. He said that effort will now encompass planning for increased severe weather.
“Through this executive order, we are creating a comprehensive response that will help us become more resilient and better prepared for future storms and climate events,” the mayor said.
It’s not clear what, exactly, that will look like.
“We’re just starting this process, but it’s a process that has to start,” Mr. Gainey said. “Because what we’ve seen in the field over the last week — it was horrific.”
Read More
The importance of the plan, he said, is that it’s a concerted effort to bake what the mayor called climate resiliency into every aspect of planning, including topics such as where housing should or shouldn’t be built.
Jamil Bey, director of city planning, called the recent storm a wakeup call — “a vivid, painful example of what climate change looks like when it reaches our doorstep.”
The brief but powerful storm knocked out power to more than 300,000 Duquesne Light customers, some of whom were left without electricity for more than a week. The city kept rec centers and senior centers open beyond normal hours to allow residents to charge electronics, and EMS crews began delivering oxygen to those who rely on it.
“A part of this is just learning where we were most vulnerable, working with our utility partners and with other agencies to better understand what’s feasible,” Mr. Bey said.
Darryl Jones, who heads the city’s fire bureau and Office of Emergency Management and Homeland Security, conceded that he wasn’t in Pittsburgh during last week’s storm; rather, he was in Myrtle Beach for the Metro Chiefs Conference. He said he informed everyone that he would be gone starting April 26 and what the chain of command would be in his absence — except for the city controller and City Council.
“And that’s my bad,” he said, noting that during the storm he remained in contact with the public safety director.
He said planning for storms like that one should be the new normal. The “old normal,” he said, is a thing of the past.
“We can never have the time that we had before the storm last week,” he said. “We have to be ready to adapt to the new normal. That process includes planning for the future.”
Planning is the operative word. The executive order, on its face, doesn’t outline what exactly the process will entail, and city leaders did not articulate tangible outcomes they hope to see.
“We don’t wait for the plan to be completed to execute the plan,” Mr. Gainey said. “I think that every phase of the plan that we put together, before we execute it, we’ll have the cost there because we’re able to look over the variables that … identify exactly what it’s going to cost.”
The first step is to look backward at the response to April 29 storm by the city, county and utility companies.
Chief Jones referred to the process as an after-action review. It’s a lookback done by emergency management after every incident, whether it’s a planned event or an emergency like last week’s storm. They look at what they did well, and they look at where they need to improve.
That report has to be done within 90 days, and it must include recommendations based on the analysis.
“The first step will probably be, ‘OK, what can we mitigate right now? What can we do right now?’ ” he said.
But, he said, that’s only part of it.
“It’s about long-term solutions that will ensure the safety and well-being of our residents for generations to come,” he said.
A 2022 report from the nonprofit Climate Central indicated that Pennsylvania was already among the states seeing the most weather-related power outages.
Across the country, according to the organization’s analysis, weather-related power outages increased by nearly 80% from 2011 to 2021 compared to the previous 10-year span from 2000 to 2010.
During that entire span, from 2000 to 2021, Pennsylvania saw the fifth-most weather-related outages, according to the report.
And while power outages were among the main concerns in the aftermath of last week’s storm, they are not the only concerns.
Earlier this year, two dozen public safety officials from around the region gathered in Downtown Pittsburgh to run through potential worst-scare scenarios for severe weather in the city. The tabletop exercise came on the heels of Hurricane Helene, which ripped through the Southeast last fall and battered places like western North Carolina and eastern Tennessee — areas hundreds of miles inland from where the Category 4 hurricane made landfall in Florida.
An event like Helene, which dumped more than a foot of rain in a matter of days, would likely be reminiscent of Pittsburgh’s 1936 St. Patrick’s Day flood in which the Ohio River swelled to 46 feet in Downtown. That’s more than 30 feet above its normal level.
That amount of water today would mean some 15 feet of water on streets in the Golden Triangle. At 36 feet, 500 businesses on the North Shore and Downtown could be flooded.
A report compiled by the First Street Foundation, a nonprofit whose climate change and flooding studies are used to inform emergency preparedness for government agencies, showed 12% of properties in the city of Pittsburgh would take on water in a 100-year flood. In simpler terms, areas in a 100-year floodplain have a 1 in 100 chance of suffering a flood in any given year.
That percentage is the ninth highest nationally in First Street’s data, putting Pittsburgh among the likes of coastal cities such as Houston, Los Angeles and Virginia Beach.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.