As the ballot count in Pennsylvania slowed to a near-halt Friday evening with Vice President Joe Biden’s lead hovering around 28,178 votes, all hope — mathematically — for Donald Trump’s presidential bid to survive rested, mostly, in batches of ballots that were as hard to quantify as they were to predict.
The exact tabulation of outstanding ballots in the battleground state was not known as of 11 p.m., but at least 63,000 were mail-in ballots received before Election Day. A small number were ballots received in the last three days under the state Supreme Court’s ballot extension. An unknown number were military and overseas ballots, and thousands — potentially more than 85,000 by some estimates — were provisional ballots cast this past Tuesday that were to be reviewed by local elections boards before officially counting.
If trends continued into the count overnight, Mr. Biden was expected to run up his margin with the 63,000-plus mail-in ballots — a number that included more than 35,000 in Allegheny County, which the elections workers had reviewed all day Friday and were set to resume Saturday. As of Friday night, Mr. Biden had been winning mail-in ballots by a more than 3-to-1 margin statewide.
Mr. Biden also was poised to pad his lead with the small number of ballots that counties received by 5 p.m. Friday, which are allowed to be tallied if they were postmarked on or before Election Day. On Friday, U.S. Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito ordered county officials to segregate these ballots from others — which state election officials had already been urging counties to do, but which the Pennsylvania Republican Party wanted in writing, the Associated Press reported.
There wasn’t yet a full tally of how many the 67 counties received, but Secretary of State Kathy Boockvar anticipated it to be “significantly lower” than officials had previously thought, and a “fraction” of what they saw in the primary. That number in the June contests was about 60,000. Allegheny County received 947 that were postmarked correctly and ready to count.
Then, there remained at least 85,000 provisional ballots, but not all of those will count. Provisional ballots have to be individually reviewed by county boards of election, and come from voters who may have experienced problems on Election Day or with their mail-in ballot. All ballots that are determined to be eligible are tallied. The counties have until next Tuesday to review them.
Read More
Provisionals represent the biggest batch of ballots that are, at this point, hard to predict using data and trends, leading some to believe that Mr. Trump could gain ground here.
Lara Putnam, a University of Pittsburgh professor who studies the electoral landscape in Western Pennsylvania, said she expects the provisional ballots to “less Biden-heavy than mail-ins, but still net Biden more votes than Trump.”
Ms. Putnam said she anticipates some provisional ballots to be driven by “the usual range of factors” that more often capture Democratic than Republican voters — like age and mobility — while the rest are driven by mail-in ballot requests that have skewed heavily pro-Democrat and pro-Biden.
She also cited data compiled by Mike Johnson, data director at the Pennsylvania AFL-CIO, who noted that in June’s primary, mail-in ballot requests by Republicans were about twice as likely to end in casting a provisional ballot. If those ratios are carried through the electorate — which is a “big assumption,” Mr. Johnson noted — “we may see a pretty similar number of [Democratic] and [Republican] provisional ballots.” He said he’d guess a “slight” Democratic advantage on their outcome.
In Allegheny County all day Friday, the election warehouse in the North Side was the center of a one-by-one review process of 35,000-plus mail-in ballots, which included more than 3,000 that “were unscannable” and needed duplicated, 4,350 that had other issues and 29,000 that needed to be checked because they made up the contents of a faulty batch of ballots sent by a contractor to voters last month.
When the count was suspended at around 10:40 p.m., the workers had counted more than 17,800 votes, including the military and absentee ballots it had so far received, the ballots that were “unscannable” and some of the 29,000 it had to reconcile. Of those, 13,870 went for Mr. Biden and 3,684 to Mr. Trump.
On Saturday morning, the elections division will continue to review the remainder of the batch of 29,000 — many of which had been completed Friday — as well as the 4,350 that were determined to have other issues, like a missing date or ineligible voter on the declaration form.
Julian Routh: jrouth@post-gazette.com. Post-Gazette staff writers Lauren Lee and Lacretia Wimbley contributed reporting.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.