In a scene that could have been pulled from the pages of a legal drama, attorneys involved in a potential class-action suit against the government debated several nebulous questions Thursday morning in a Downtown courtroom:

• Should traveling by air with large amounts of cash be deemed suspicious or illegal?

• Was the seizure of a retired railroad engineer’s life savings — more than $82,000 in cash — justified?

• Does the Transportation Security Administration have “secret policies” that violate travelers’ Fourth Amendment rights?

Advertise with us

Attorneys for the government refuted all allegations of wrongdoing and said law enforcement should investigate when a potential crime is suspected.

But lawyers representing plaintiffs in the suit against the TSA, Drug Enforcement Administration, the U.S. Government and others countered that the actions against travelers carrying large amounts of cash were illegal.

“These policies tell screeners when you encounter large amounts of cash — even after you’ve cleared it and made sure there’s no bombs or guns or other threats — you’re still supposed to conduct a series of investigative steps,” attorney Dan Alban said.

“Those policies, on their face, are illegal and unconstitutional.”

An incident at Pittsburgh International

The lawsuit revolves around the case of Terry Rolin, who has since died.

Advertise with us

Rolin grew up in a household shaped by the Great Depression, according to his daughter, Rebecca Brown. He shared his parents’ distrust of banks and squirreled away his money, in cash, in various hiding spots around his house in Cuddy, an unincorporated area near Bridgeville.

When he moved to a smaller apartment outside South Fayette Township in 2018 at age 79, he gathered the cash and asked his daughter to fly with it to her home in Boston and create a new joint account.

Ms. Brown, who was visiting family in Pittsburgh in 2019, agreed to do so, according to the lawsuit.

Before she could board her plane at Pittsburgh International Airport on Aug. 26, 2019, TSA agents “observed via X-ray that [her carry-on luggage] contained a ‘large’ amount of cash,’ ” the lawsuit states.

TSA screeners “told her they were going to hold on to her carry-on luggage until law enforcement officers could arrive,” the lawsuit states. Agents summoned Drug Enforcement Agency agent Steve Dawkin, who took possession of the money, the lawsuit states.

Advertise with us

“They questioned Rebecca about why she had so much cash [and] told her to give them her ID and proof of her travel arrangements,” the lawsuit continues.

“Rebecca had no items that could threaten transportation security — weapons, explosives, incendiaries, or other prohibited items — in her carry-on luggage or on her person. She also had no illegal drugs or any other contraband. But rather than permit Rebecca to continue to her gate, the TSA Screeners unlawfully prolonged Rebecca’s detention,” the lawsuit states.

Ms. Brown hired an attorney. She eventually recovered her father’s money before he died in 2022, but only after a seven-month battle in which the DEA tried to keep it via civil forfeiture, she claimed in the lawsuit.

During that time, her father was unable to afford medical care, including a new set of dentures that he needed, she said.

‘Cash is not a threat’

Ms. Brown and her attorneys from the Institute for Justice, a Virginia-based nonprofit public interest law firm, said Thursday they want to ensure that what she and her father experienced never happens again.

Advertise with us

“This is an unlawful procedure that TSA is putting travelers through, and it has to be stopped,” Ms. Brown said during a news conference in a hotel down the street from the courthouse.

The lawsuit, which seeks to represent others who allege they have had money seized by the government, started in 2020. Following a five-year discovery period, the two sides finally convened in Downtown on Thursday for oral arguments at the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Pennsylvania.

Government attorney Sarah Suwanda asked the court to dismiss the case without prejudice.

The TSA is not required to ignore evidence of potential criminal activity during a lawful search, she said, and cash seizures are “exceedingly rare.”

Mr. Alban alleged that the TSA maintained “secret written policies” directing screeners to subject travelers carrying “large amounts” of cash to heightened scrutiny in violation of the Fourth Amendment, which protects citizens from unreasonable searches and seizures.

Advertise with us

He said that the TSA has variously defined a “large amount of cash” in its depositions as anywhere from $10,000 to as little as $100 in $1 bills.

He added that it is “undisputed that cash is not a threat.”

Ms. Suwanda noted that because Rolin is dead, there is no chance he will be harmed in the future.

Mr. Alban responded that while Rolin is no longer an active plaintiff, the other plaintiffs — recreational gambler Stacy Jones-Nasr and California limousine and tour bus company owner Matthew Berger — continue to be impacted by their experiences with the TSA.

Magistrate Judge Kezia O.L. Taylor said that she would take the case under advisement.

She did not provide a timeline. She will send her Report and Recommendation — a document proposing a resolution— to District Judge Marilyn J. Horan, who will issue the final opinion.